Questions and discussion
Knowing it is working

Asking, waiting and handling what comes back

Most questions in most rooms are answered by the person who asked them, about a second later. This chapter writes the questions down in advance, holds the pause, and plans for the four situations that reliably derail a room.

Start here Essentials

Two things make questions work: writing them down in advance, and waiting longer than feels comfortable after asking. Both are decided before the day.

  1. Write the two or three questions you will actually ask, in full. Onto the run sheet (section 2).
  2. Decide the pause you will leave, and how you will measure it. Counting, a hand on the bench, a glance at a clock (section 1).
  3. Plan one think-pair-share where you would otherwise ask the whole room. Pick the question that most deserves a real answer (section 3).
  4. Write your sentence for a question you cannot answer. One line, ready (section 4).

Minimum time: about 25 minutes. Done when: your questions are written word for word on the run sheet with a pause marked against each, and you have a sentence ready for "I do not know".

1. The pause nobody holds Understand

You ask a question. Nobody answers. You rephrase it, or answer it yourself, and move on, and the room learns that your questions are rhetorical.

The K. Patricia Cross Academy at the University of Alabama, in its article Wait for It! Improving Student Responses by Increasing Wait Time, reports that in a typical college classroom most teachers pose a question and wait less than one second. The recommendation on the page is three to seven seconds. Convention That range is the single most actionable thing in this chapter, and it is free.

One second is not enough time to parse a question, retrieve anything, decide whether the retrieved thing is right, and decide whether to say it in front of strangers. Three to seven seconds is enough for the first three for most people, which is why the pause produces answers from people who had one and were not fast enough to offer it.

The same page reports that teachers find the pause uncomfortable at first, and that it helps to tell the group what you are doing. That instruction is worth following literally. "I am going to ask this and then wait, so take a few seconds" removes the social meaning of the silence: it stops being a failure in the room and becomes a procedure. Say it once at the start and the pauses afterwards cost nothing.

Measuring it

Three seconds is longer than it feels when you are at the front. Ways to measure it without staring at a clock:

  • Count silently. One elephant, two elephant. Unreliable when you are nervous, and better than nothing.
  • Do something physical. Walk three steps, put down the tool, pick up your notes, write the question on the board. All of them take about the right amount of time and none of them looks like waiting.
  • Look at the back of the room. Moving your gaze away takes the pressure off the people in front, and it gives you a reason to take a breath.

The hardest version is the pause after somebody has answered, which section 5 is about and which the same source says matters even more.

2. Writing the questions out

Most questions in most sessions are improvised, and improvised questions have predictable faults. They are too broad to answer ("so, what do you think?"), they are double questions where the second overwrites the first, or they are statements with a question mark on the end ("so you would check the seal first, right?").

Writing two or three out in full, in the run sheet, fixes all three and takes ten minutes. It also lets you notice what the question is for, which is the thing that decides its shape:

What the question is forShape that worksExample
Finding out whether they can do the next thingA check with options, answered by everybody at onceSee Checks for understanding: finding out whether it landed
Surfacing what they already doOpen, about their own experience, low risk to answer"What do you do now when the dough sticks?"
Making them predict before you showBinary or short, with a commitment"Will this one spread or hold? Say it to the person next to you."
Getting the room to notice somethingPointed at a specific thing you are about to do"Watch my left hand. What is it doing that my right is not?"
Opening a discussionGenuinely open, with more than one defensible answer"Where would you use this at home, and where would you not bother?"

A prediction question is worth singling out. Asking people to commit to an answer before they see the result changes what they see: they are now watching to find out whether they were right. It costs fifteen seconds and it turns a demonstration from something that happens at people into something they have a stake in.

3. Asking fewer people at once

Asking a room of twenty-four produces one answer from the same person each time. Asking twelve pairs produces twelve answers, all at once, and people who would not speak to the room will say something to one person.

The University of Connecticut's page on active learning lists Think-Pair-Share among its techniques by group size, along with Think-Write-Pair-Share, Note Comparison, Peer Review and about a dozen others. The mechanics of think-pair-share are simple and the parts are each load-bearing:

  1. Think. Silent, alone, with a stated number of seconds. Without this the pair conversation is dominated by whoever speaks first.
  2. Pair. Two people, with a stated job: agree on one answer, or find where you disagree. A pair with no job has a chat.
  3. Share. Not every pair. Take three, or ask for a show of hands on the two positions, or collect one sentence per pair on paper.

The write variant, where people write before they pair, costs another thirty seconds and produces better pairs, because each person has something to say rather than reconstructing it on the spot.

Two practical notes. Make the pairs yourself when you know the experience spread and the room does not, which Finding out what the room already knows covers. And give the share a shape: "I want one sentence from three pairs" is a bounded request; "what did people come up with?" is an open mic.

Limits

Discussion is not evidence that anybody can do the thing. A room can talk well about a skill and fail at it, and talking is more comfortable than attempting, for them and for you. Treat discussion as a way to surface reasoning and misunderstandings, and keep the judgment about ability for a check or a practice block. Where the two disagree, the hands are telling the truth.

4. The four situations that derail a room

Four things happen in most rooms. Having a sentence ready for each is most of what handling them consists of.

The person who answers everything

Usually enthusiastic, often knowledgeable, and the effect on the room is that everybody else stops trying. The cheapest fixes are structural rather than personal: think-pair-share, which removes the race; naming who answers, "let me take one from someone who has not spoken yet"; and giving the person a job, "can you watch the back bench for me and tell me what you see". Address the structure before you address the person, because a quiet word is a last resort that costs you their goodwill.

The person who is lost and will not say so

This is the one a check catches and a discussion does not. The person has stopped following, is embarrassed, and will not raise a hand. The remedy is not to ask them; it is to make the state visible without naming anybody, which is what a check does, and to build in a moment where being behind is normal: "most people find the third step awkward the first time, so I am going to do it again."

The question that is really a complaint

"Why do we even have to use this new system?" is not a question about the system. Answering it as if it were produces a defense of a decision you may not have made. What works: acknowledge it as a real thing, say where it belongs, and return to the session. "That is a fair question and it is not mine to answer. I can show you how to do it quickly, and I will pass on that it came up." Said once, without irritation, it usually ends there.

The question that is a request for free consulting

"So on my setup at home, I have this specific configuration..." Answering it in full spends the room's time on one person's problem. What works: name the shape of the answer, then move it. "The short answer is X. Come and find me in the break and we will look at the specifics." Then do find them in the break, because the offer is the part that makes the deflection fair.

The one you cannot answer

Write this sentence down now: "I do not know. I will find out and send it round." The reason to write it is that in the moment the temptation is to produce something plausible, and a confident wrong answer from the person teaching is more expensive than a shrug. Then keep the second half of the promise, which also gives you a reason to email everybody afterwards.

5. Wait time 2, and what Rowe recorded Go deeper

The wait-time article distinguishes two pauses, from Rowe's work: wait time 1 is the pause after the question, and wait time 2 is the pause after a student's response. The page states that wait time 2 matters even more.

That is the harder one. Somebody answers, and the reflex is to evaluate immediately: "yes, good". Doing so ends the thought, tells the room the answer is closed, and gives you only the first thing that person said rather than the second. Waiting two or three seconds after an answer, looking at the person, produces elaboration, and sometimes produces the correction they were about to make themselves.

The page lists the effects Rowe identified from longer wait times: longer student responses, more unsolicited appropriate responses, more speculative responses, fewer non-responding students, more responses from students their teachers had identified as slow learners, and higher achievement test scores. It also mentions Stahl's four kinds of think time, extending the idea beyond the two pauses.

Convention One note on attribution. The page attributes the concept to Rowe "in the 1950s"; other citations give dates in the late 1960s and the 1970s, and this manual names Rowe without asserting a first-publication year.

Two further pauses worth building in, which follow the same logic. After somebody asks you a question, pause before answering: it models the behavior and it stops you answering a question you have misheard. And after you finish an explanation, pause before asking whether it landed, so that the question is not stepping on the end of your own sentence.

6. Repeating the question, and why it is an access matter Go deeper

Somebody at the front asks a question and you answer it. Half the room heard a mumble and then an answer to something unknown.

The W3C's checklist for making events accessible lists repeating audience questions into the microphone among the things a speaker does. It sits alongside describing all relevant visual information, speaking clearly, using simple language with jargon explained, giving people time to process, and being visible and well lit.

So this is not a courtesy to the people at the back. A person using an assistive listening device hears what goes through the microphone and nothing else; a captioner captions what they can hear; somebody lip-reading can read you and not the person behind them. Repeating the question is the thing that keeps them in the session.

Two habits make it automatic. Repeat every question, including the ones you think were audible, so that you do not have to judge each time. And repeat it as a restatement rather than a quotation, which also gives you a second to think and lets you check you understood: "the question is whether this works with a wetter dough."

What else to do with the room, and who is responsible for the microphone in the first place, is in Access: what to ask, what to arrange, who decides and Setting up a room people can actually work in.

7. What the market teaches about difficult participants Go deeper

Train-the-trainer products sell this part hard. The Bob Pike Group's Train-the-Trainer Boot Camp page lists seven types of difficult participant among the seven things participants will discover, alongside twenty audience-engagement strategies.

We have the marketing page and not the classroom, so this manual does not say what that course teaches about them or whether it is any good. What is worth noticing is the framing itself, because framing a room in terms of difficult types has a cost. It locates the problem in the person, which points you at managing people rather than at changing the structure, and the structural fixes in section 4 are cheaper, work without a confrontation, and tend to address the actual cause. The person who answers everything is responding to a format that rewards speed; change the format and the behavior changes without anybody being handled.

The other cost is that typing people is usually wrong about them. The person asking the awkward question may be the only one willing to say what the room is thinking, and the quiet one may be the most capable person present. Treat behavior as information about the session's design before you treat it as information about the person.

8. See it See it

Fictional example

Marisol and the person who answers everything. Twenty-four staff, three hours, a borrowed conference room, one co-facilitator (Teo). One participant, by reputation, answers every question in every meeting.

Known: twenty-four people at laptops, mixed experience, and a room arranged in rows, which she can change.

Her three written questions: (1) "What do you do now when a total stops updating?" (2) "Looking at this sheet: will the formula survive if I insert a row above it? Yes or no, say it to the person next to you." (3) "Where in your own work would a pivot table save you an hour a week, and where would it be overkill?"

What she does structurally: question 2 is a prediction asked as a pair, so the fast answerer has one listener rather than twenty-three. Question 1 she asks with a written pause: she writes it on the whiteboard, which takes about eight seconds, and in that time four people have an answer ready.

Her pause plan: she tells the room once, at the start: "I will ask things and then wait. The silence is on purpose."

Her sentence for the unanswerable: "I do not know. I will find out and send it round." Teo has agreed to write those down as they come.

Assumed, and whose assumption it is: Marisol assumes the fast answerer will accept a watching job rather than feel sidelined. That is her assumption. She plans the structural moves first and keeps the quiet word in reserve, so that the assumption being wrong costs little.

Open, and who settles it: whether the room's rows can be turned into pairs facing each other. The building's facilities team settles that, and she asks before the day rather than moving furniture at nine o'clock.

9. Practice Practice

Minimum: three questions written in full, with a pause marked on each. Time: about 25 minutes. Materials: the run sheet in your session plan.

  1. Write three questions in full. One to surface what they already do, one prediction before a demonstration, one genuinely open.
  2. Mark the purpose of each. From the table in section 2. If two have the same purpose, cut one.
  3. Decide the pause and how you will fill it. Write the physical action next to each: write it on the board, put the tool down, walk to the back.
  4. Convert one to a think-pair-share. Write the thinking time, the pair's job and the shape of the share.
  5. Write your four sentences. For the talker, the complaint, the free-consulting request and the question you cannot answer.
Go deeper

Practice wait time 2 somewhere with no stakes: in a conversation this week, after the other person finishes a sentence, wait three seconds before replying. It is uncomfortable, and the most common result is that they keep talking and say the more interesting thing second. That is the effect you are trying to produce in the room, and feeling it once in private makes it much easier to hold in front of twenty people.

10. Your session Your session

11. Check your work Check your work

Criteria

  • Are your questions written word for word, in the run sheet?
  • Does each one have a purpose you could name, and are two of them not the same purpose?
  • Is there a pause marked against each, with a physical action to fill it?
  • Is at least one question asked in pairs rather than to the whole room?
  • Do you have a sentence ready for a question you cannot answer?

Worked example

Marisol's three questions are written out, with distinct purposes: current practice, prediction, application. Each has a pause, and question 1's pause is filled by writing it on the board, which is the most reliable version because it is visible work rather than waiting. Question 2 is a pair question. Her unanswerable sentence is written and somebody is assigned to record the questions it produces. Five criteria met. What her plan does not yet cover is wait time 2, the pause after an answer, which is the harder habit and the one she can practice this week.

Common mistakes

  • Answering your own question. It happens at about the two-second mark, and it teaches the room that the questions are rhetorical.
  • Rephrasing immediately. A rephrase resets the clock and adds a second question on top of the first.
  • Asking the whole room what a pair could answer. One answer from the fastest person, instead of twelve answers at once.
  • Taking a complaint as a question. You end up defending a decision that is not yours.
  • Not repeating the question. Half the room hears an answer to something they did not hear, and some of them did not hear the asker.
  • Bluffing. A confident wrong answer costs more than a shrug and a follow-up email.

What is still unresolved

This chapter does not tell you what to do with the information a discussion produces, which is a judgment about whether to move on, and that judgment is what a check is for: Checks for understanding: finding out whether it landed. The minutes that questions and pauses consume are priced in Workshop timing: minutes on paper and minutes in the room. And the arrangement of the room, including whether people can hear each other in pairs, is Setting up a room people can actually work in.

12. Knowledge check and scenario

How long do teachers typically wait after asking a question, and what is recommended?
Published guidance reports that in a typical college classroom most teachers wait less than one second, and recommends three to seven seconds. The same source notes that teachers find the pause uncomfortable at first and that it helps to tell the group what you are doing, which converts the silence from an awkward gap into a stated procedure.
Why is wait time 2 described as mattering even more than wait time 1?
Because the pause after somebody answers is what lets them elaborate or correct themselves, and because an immediate evaluation closes the thought for the whole room. The first thing a person says is rarely the most interesting thing they have; waiting two or three seconds, looking at them, is what gets the second one.
Why repeat audience questions, even in a small room?
Because a person using an assistive listening device hears what goes through the microphone, a captioner captions what they can hear, and somebody lip-reading can read you and not the person behind them. The W3C event checklist lists it as a speaker's item. Doing it every time, as a restatement, also checks that you understood the question.
(Go deeper) What is the cost of framing a room in terms of difficult participant types?
It locates the problem in the person, which points you toward managing individuals rather than changing the format. The structural fixes are usually cheaper and avoid a confrontation: the person who answers everything is responding to a format that rewards speed, and think-pair-share removes the race without anybody being handled. Typing people also tends to be wrong about them.
You ask a question and get silence. You have waited about two seconds and it already feels long. What do you do?
The most common reflex and usually the wrong one. Rephrasing resets the clock and puts a second question on top of the first, so people who were halfway to an answer start again. If the question genuinely was unclear you will find that out after the pause, from the answers you get.
Two seconds is under the recommended range, and the physical action buys you the rest without looking like waiting. Writing the question up is the strongest version: it takes about the right amount of time, it leaves the question visible for people who are still parsing it, and it gives you something to do with your hands.
A good move and better used by design than as a rescue. If you reach for it every time silence appears, you lose the chance for the room to learn that your pauses are real. Plan one think-pair-share in advance, for the question that most deserves a real answer, and hold the pause on the others.

Checklist

Records your learning only; it is not a qualification.