Timing
Knowing it is working

Workshop timing: minutes on paper and minutes in the room

The run sheet that adds up, the buffer you chose on purpose, and the cut list you write before the day so that the thing you drop at the halfway point is the thing you meant to drop.

Start here Essentials

Put numbers on the run sheet, watch the total go over, and decide what goes first while you are calm rather than at the halfway point while you are not.

  1. Put your segments in the session budget calculator and see what is left over. The timing calculators do the arithmetic (section 2).
  2. Add the minutes the checks actually cost. Using the published timings rather than a guess (section 3).
  3. Work out practice time per person. The figure that moves most (section 3).
  4. Set a buffer and watch the total go negative. That is the exercise working (section 4).
  5. Write the cut list in the order you will cut. First, second, third (section 5).

Minimum time: about 40 minutes. Done when: the run sheet totals no more than your session length with the buffer in it, and a cut list exists naming what goes first, second and third.

1. Where the minutes actually go Understand

Sessions overrun in predictable places, and they are rarely the places people plan for. The teaching segments are usually close to their estimate. What eats the session is the set of things nobody wrote on the sheet.

What takes the minutesTypical costWhy it is missed
Arrival and settlingFive to ten minutes past the start timeThe sheet starts at the advertised time; the room does not
Handing out materialsA minute per thing, more if people have to moveIt feels instantaneous when you imagine it
Moving between arrangementsTwo to four minutes each wayChairs, tables and twelve people do not reconfigure silently
The demonstration repeatedThe length of the demonstration, againSomebody at the back did not see it, which you find out afterwards
The one long questionThree to eight minutesOne person's specific case, answered in full in front of everyone
Changeover at a stationA minute per turn, times every turnInvisible in the plan and large in the aggregate
The check that comes back badlyFive to ten minutes to reteachPlanned for as a thing that will go well

Three of these are worth putting on the sheet as rows of their own: arrival, materials handout and any room reconfiguration. They are real segments with real minutes, and writing them down converts them from an overrun into a plan.

The rest is what the buffer is for, which is section 4, and the uncomfortable part of that section is that nobody can tell you how big it should be.

2. The session budget

The session budget calculator takes the fixed costs first: the opening, the closing, any break, and the buffer as a percentage. It subtracts them, then subtracts the practice blocks and the checks, and tells you how many minutes are left for the teaching segments and how many that is each.

Doing it in that order matters. Most people plan the teaching first and give whatever is left to practice, which is how practice ends up as the last twelve minutes of a ninety-minute session. Taking the practice and the checks out first is the same arithmetic in the order that protects the part people came for.

A worked example, with a ninety-minute session:

ItemMinutesRunning total left
Session length9090
Opening585
Closing580
Buffer at 10 percent of 90971
Two practice blocks of 153041
Two checks at 4 minutes833
Left for teaching segments33, which is three segments of 11

Thirty-three minutes of explaining and demonstrating in a ninety-minute session is less than most people picture, and it is a realistic figure once practice is protected. If your draft had fifty minutes of teaching, something has to give, and section 5 is about deciding what while you are calm.

3. Pricing the checks and the practice

Two of the items in that table have published or calculable figures, which makes them worth pricing properly rather than estimating.

What a check costs

The check cycle calculator builds a check from four parts: the pause after the question, the thinking time alone, the pair discussion, and the re-poll with the explanation.

Two of those have published figures. The ConcepTest protocol published by the Science Education Resource Center gives thirty seconds to one minute for individuals to consider the question and choose an answer, and one to two minutes for the pair discussion when the first count falls in the useful band. The wait-time guidance gives a minimum pause of about three seconds after asking, which is the floor rather than the thinking time. Convention The re-poll and the explanation have no published figure that we found, so that input starts at zero and you supply it from your own experience.

With the published defaults, one full check cycle runs to roughly three to four minutes. Two checks is most of ten minutes, and that is the honest price of knowing whether your session is working. Checks for understanding: finding out whether it landed is where the check itself gets written.

What practice costs per person

The practice time calculator divides the station minutes you have by the attempts the room needs. Twenty minutes, three stations, six people, two attempts each gives 60 station minutes across 12 attempts: five minutes per attempt including changeover, four minutes of hands on the work if changeover is a minute.

Run it the other way when the first answer is too small. Decide the attempt length you need, and the calculator returns the block length that produces it. That number is often the thing that decides the whole shape of the session, which is why Designing the part where they do it asks for it before you commit to a run sheet.

4. The buffer, which has no correct value

You will see advice to leave ten percent, or twenty percent, or "twenty minutes in a half day". None of it has a source behind it, and this manual is not going to add another number to the pile.

What a buffer is for, concretely: the demonstration repeated for somebody at the back, the one long question, the check that comes back at 25 percent, a late start, and the material that takes longer with twelve people than it did with you alone. Those are the events it absorbs, and how often they happen in your subject is something you know and we do not.

Limits

The calculator ships with the buffer at zero and no suggested figure, on purpose. No source in this manual's resource library publishes one, and a default in a calculator reads as a recommendation. What we can say is what the buffer absorbs, that a session with none of it overruns in the places listed in section 1, and that your own recorded minutes from After the workshop: what happened and what to change are a better source for your buffer than any published figure would be.

A practical way to arrive at a figure without inventing one: list the events above that are plausible in your session, put a minute figure on each from your own experience, add them up, and use that as the buffer. If that comes to twenty-five minutes of a ninety-minute session, you have learned something useful about the plan, which is that it is too full.

5. The cut list, written before the day

At the halfway point you will be behind. This is close to universal and it is not a sign of failure; it is a sign that the plan was optimistic, which plans are.

The question is what you drop, and the worst time to decide is while it is happening, because under time pressure people cut the thing that is easiest to cut rather than the thing that matters least. In practice that means the closing, the last check and the second practice block, which are three of the most valuable items on the sheet.

So write the list in advance, in order, in the run sheet or beside it:

  1. First to go. Usually a teaching segment whose material is in the handout. Say out loud that you are skipping it and where to read it.
  2. Second. Usually the depth on an objective marked "if there is room" rather than essential.
  3. Third. Usually the number of attempts in the second practice block, from three to two.

Two things to protect at the top of the list, and to say so explicitly: the check attached to your most important objective, and the closing. The check is how you know; the closing is what leaves the room. A session that ends mid-sentence because the clock ran out has thrown away the two minutes where people write down what they will do next.

One more entry worth writing: what you will do if you are ahead. It happens, and the default is to fill the time with talking. Better options, written in advance: another attempt, a harder variation, or letting people go early, which is a legitimate use of time and rarely resented.

6. Reading the clock without staring at it Go deeper

Two problems: knowing where you are, and not visibly checking.

The fix for the first is clock times on the run sheet, not durations. "11:20 practice two" is readable in a glance; "15 minutes for practice two" requires arithmetic you will get wrong while talking. Write both columns, with the clock times calculated from your planned start, and accept that they will drift.

The fix for the second is placement. A clock or a phone face-up on the bench where you stand, in your sightline when you look down at the work, is invisible to the room. A watch requires a gesture everybody reads. If you have a helper, the cheapest arrangement is to ask them to tell you at two fixed points: "halfway" and "ten minutes left", said quietly, which is also a prompt to look at the cut list.

The halfway point is the moment to use. Check where you are against the sheet, and if you are behind, cut now rather than at ten minutes left. Cutting early preserves the end of the session; cutting late means the end is what gets cut.

7. Running it a second time, with your own figures Go deeper

Everything in this chapter is estimation until you have taught the session once. After that you have the only figures that are actually about your subject, your room and your group.

The sheet that collects them is "What happened" in After the workshop: what happened and what to change: one row per segment, planned minutes and actual minutes side by side, both columns totaling. Filling it within a day is the whole trick, because the memory of where the minutes went fades faster than the memory of how it felt.

What to do with the figures on the second run:

  • Use the actual minutes as the plan. Not the planned ones. If the demonstration took eleven minutes, it takes eleven minutes.
  • Look at the total gap, not the row gaps. If the whole session ran twelve minutes over, that is your buffer figure, derived rather than invented.
  • Notice which rows were stable. Rows that match their estimate are rows you can trust in the next plan; rows that did not are rows to split or price differently.

By the third run you are working from measurements rather than from conventions, which is the position this manual would like you to reach, and the reason it declines to give you a buffer figure in the meantime.

8. The prep calendar, when you have a date Go deeper

Minutes in the room are one kind of timing. The other kind is the two weeks before, where the things that go wrong are other people's deadlines rather than yours.

The prep calendar in your session plan counts back from the date in your setup and fills in dated rows. Every row names who set the deadline, which is the column that matters: a task you set yourself can move, and a task the venue or a supplier set cannot. The rows that most often fail are the ones depending on somebody else, and they are the ones that need chasing a day before they are due rather than on the day.

If you have no date yet, the calendar shows the same rows as days before, and they become dates the moment you add one in setup.

9. See it See it

Fictional example

Priya's two hours, priced. Ten people, five benches, two hours at the community kitchen, one helper.

Her first draft: opening 10, introduction to dough 15, demonstration 15, practice 25, second demonstration 10, practice 25, questions 10, closing 10. That totals 120, with no buffer and no checks.

What the budget calculator showed once she added two checks at four minutes each and a 10 percent buffer of 12 minutes: she was 20 minutes over.

Known: 120 minutes, ten people, five benches, dough prepared in advance by the kitchen.

Assumed, and whose assumption it is: that a beginner's attempt takes three minutes. Priya's assumption, from watching one person. Under that assumption two blocks of fifteen minutes give three attempts each; if beginners take four minutes, it gives two.

What she cut, in order: introduction to dough went from 15 to 0, into the handout, since it is background and a page carries it. Questions stopped being a segment; she takes them during practice. Opening went from 10 to 5.

Her sheet now: opening 5, demonstration 12, practice 15, check 4, second demonstration 8, practice 15, check 4, closing 5. That is 68 minutes of plan in a 120-minute session, with 12 minutes of buffer and 40 minutes she has deliberately left unallocated because it is her first time teaching anything and she expects to be slow.

Her cut list: first the second demonstration, second one attempt from the second practice block, third the first two minutes of the closing. Protected: the first check, and the last three minutes of the closing where people write down what they will bake this week.

Open, and who settles it: whether the kitchen's dough will be ready at the hour she is promised. The kitchen manager settles that, and it is the row on her prep calendar with somebody else's name against it.

10. Practice Practice

Minimum: the budget calculator run once with your real segments, and a cut list of three items. Time: about 40 minutes. Materials: your run sheet and the timing calculators.

  1. Put your segments into the session budget. Total minutes, opening, closing, break, and the counts of segments, practice blocks and checks.
  2. Price one check and use the figure. Run the check cycle calculator with the published defaults, then put the result into the minutes-per-check field.
  3. Price the practice. Run the practice time calculator and check that the minutes per attempt match what one attempt actually takes a beginner.
  4. Add a buffer built from events, not from a percentage. List what could eat time in your session, put minutes on each, add them up.
  5. Write the cut list in order, and write what you will do if you are ahead. Both go beside the run sheet.
Go deeper

Add clock times to the run sheet from your planned start, and then add two markers: "halfway" against the row that should be running at the midpoint, and "ten minutes left" against the row that should be running near the end. On the day, those two markers are the only clock arithmetic you have to do. If you have a helper, give them the same two markers and ask them to say the word quietly at each.

11. Your session Your session

12. Check your work Check your work

Criteria

  • Does the run sheet total no more than your session length, with the buffer counted?
  • Are arrival, materials handout and any room reconfiguration on the sheet as rows?
  • Is the minutes-per-check figure from the calculator rather than a guess?
  • Does the practice arithmetic give each person an attempt long enough to be worth taking?
  • Is there a written cut list, in order, with the check and the closing protected?

Worked example

Priya's sheet totals 68 minutes of plan plus 12 of buffer in a 120-minute session, which leaves 40 minutes unallocated. That is a large margin and she has a reason for it: first time teaching, borrowed kitchen, dough she has not worked with. Her checks are priced at four minutes from the calculator. Her practice arithmetic gives three minutes per attempt against an assumed three-minute beginner attempt, which is tight, and she has written it down as tight. Her cut list is in order with the right two things protected. Her gap: arrival is not on the sheet as a row, and the kitchen is borrowed, so the first five minutes will go somewhere.

Common mistakes

  • Planning the teaching first and giving the rest to practice. It is the same arithmetic in the order that eats the practice.
  • A buffer copied from somewhere. Build it from the events you can name in your own session.
  • No row for arrival or handouts. They take minutes and they take them from the beginning, where you are least able to absorb it.
  • Deciding the cut in the room. Under pressure people cut what is easy, which is the closing and the last check.
  • Durations rather than clock times. You will do the arithmetic wrong while talking.
  • Not writing down what to do if you are ahead. The default is to fill it with talking.

What is still unresolved

This chapter does not decide what belongs in the session; cutting sends you back to Writing learning objectives: what they will be able to do, where the not-today list already exists. It does not tell you how long your own demonstration takes, which only a stopwatch and Showing someone how, so they can see it can settle. And every estimate here is replaced by measurement once you have taught it once, which is what Did the training work? Finding out afterward, and changing the session collects.

13. Knowledge check and scenario

Why does the budget calculator subtract practice and checks before the teaching segments?
Because the order protects the part people came for. The arithmetic is identical either way, but planning the teaching first and giving the remainder to practice is how practice becomes the last twelve minutes of a ninety-minute session. Taking it out first makes the teaching segments the compressible item, which is what they should be, since most of what they carry can go into a handout.
Where do the check cycle calculator's default timings come from, and which input has no default?
The thirty seconds to one minute of individual thinking and the one to two minutes of pair discussion come from the published ConcepTest protocol; the three-second minimum pause comes from the wait-time guidance. The re-poll and explanation time has no published figure we found, so it starts at zero and you supply it from your own experience.
Why write the cut list before the day?
Because at the halfway point, under pressure, people cut what is easiest rather than what matters least, which usually means the closing, the last check and the second practice block. A list written while calm puts a teaching segment first, protects the check and the closing explicitly, and turns a panicked decision into reading a line.
(Go deeper) How do you arrive at a buffer figure without a published one?
List the events that could eat time in your particular session: a repeated demonstration, one long question, a check that comes back badly, a late start, slower work with a group than alone. Put a minute figure on each from your own experience and add them up. After the first run, replace the whole thing with the gap between planned and actual totals from your own records.
You are at the halfway point of a ninety-minute session and you are twelve minutes behind. Your cut list says the first thing to go is a teaching segment. What do you do?
Cutting early preserves the end of the session, which is where the check and the closing live. Saying it out loud costs ten seconds and does two things: it stops people wondering whether you forgot, and it points them at the handout, which is where that material was most useful anyway.
Speeding up is the reflex and it does not work. You cannot recover twelve minutes by talking faster, and a demonstration done faster is the exact failure that chapter five is about: merged steps and blocked views. What usually happens is that you arrive at ten minutes left still behind, with the closing to cut.
Deferring the decision is understandable and it costs you the cheap cut. At ten minutes left the only things left to cut are the closing and the last check, which are the two items the cut list protects. If you do wait, decide now what you will drop then, so the decision is already made.

Checklist

Records your learning only; it is not a qualification.