Practice
Building the session

Designing the part where they do it

One attempt, defined. How many of them fit. Where you stand while they happen, what you say to someone who has it wrong, and what the people waiting for a station are doing meanwhile.

Start here Essentials

This is the part of the session where people get better at the thing. It is also the part that gets squeezed. Design it with numbers rather than with hope.

  1. For each performance, write what one attempt looks like. Small enough to say in a sentence (section 2).
  2. Decide how many attempts fit. Use the practice time calculator; the answer is usually smaller than you expect (section 3).
  3. Decide where you will be standing during each block. Write the position down (section 4).
  4. Write the one thing you will say to somebody who has done it wrong. In advance, for each likely error (section 4).
  5. Write what the people who are waiting are doing. Something specific, not "observe" (section 5).

Minimum time: about 40 minutes. Done when: every objective has a row in the practice design sheet of your demonstration and practice sheets naming one attempt, a number of attempts, and a written answer for the people not currently at a station.

1. What practice is, and what repetition is Understand

Doing a thing twenty times is not the same as practicing it twenty times. The difference is that practice has a target and feedback: the person knows what they are trying to produce, and something tells them whether they produced it.

Carnegie Mellon's learning principles state it as one of seven: goal-directed practice coupled with targeted feedback improves the quality of learning. Convention Both halves are load-bearing. Practice without a target produces twenty versions of whatever the person did first. Practice without feedback lets an error get comfortable, which is worse than not practicing, because an established habit takes longer to change than an absence.

The same page says mastery needs three things together: the component skills, practice integrating them, and knowing when to apply what. In a two-hour session you will get the first and some of the second. The third mostly happens afterwards, which is a reason to be modest about what one session achieves and a reason the thing people take home matters.

So a practice block has four parts, and the design work is naming each one:

PartThe question it answersWhat it looks like when it is missing
The attemptWhat exactly is one go?People do different amounts and finish at different times with no shared result
The targetWhat are they trying to produce?Twenty variations of the first attempt, with no self-correction
The feedbackWhat tells them whether they got it?People leave confident and wrong
The numberHow many goes does each person get?The block runs until the clock stops it, which favors the fast

2. Defining one attempt

An attempt is the smallest unit of doing that produces something you could look at. "Practice shaping" is not an attempt. "Shape one loaf and stand it on the bench" is: it has a start, an end and a visible result.

Three tests for a well-defined attempt:

  • You can say it in a sentence. If the description needs three sentences, it is probably two attempts.
  • It ends in something visible. A loaf standing, a cartridge on the bench, a formula returning a number, a form with three errors circled. The visible end is what makes feedback possible and what makes the check in Checks for understanding: finding out whether it landed cheap.
  • It takes a knowable number of minutes. Time one yourself. The figure you need for the arithmetic is your own measured time, and a beginner will take longer, often two or three times longer on a first attempt.

Write the attempt into the practice design sheet before anything else, because the number of attempts, the materials and the block length all follow from it. If one attempt consumes a piece of material, the attempt definition also tells you how much material to buy, which the materials calculator turns into packs.

3. How many attempts fit

This is arithmetic and it surprises people, so do it before you commit to a number.

The practice time calculator takes the block length, the number of stations, the number of participants, the attempts per person and the changeover time, and returns the minutes each person actually gets on the work. The shape of it is simple: the station minutes you have are the block length times the number of stations, and they are divided by the number of attempts the whole room needs.

A worked case. Twenty minutes, three stations, six people, two attempts each. That is 60 station minutes and 12 attempts, so 5 minutes per attempt including changeover. If changeover is a minute, each attempt is four minutes of hands on the work. Whether four minutes is enough for one attempt is a question about your skill, and only you can answer it.

The same arithmetic run the other way is more useful: decide how long one attempt needs, and the calculator tells you what block length that requires. If the answer is longer than your session, something has to change: fewer attempts, more stations, fewer people, or a smaller attempt.

Limits

Nobody can tell you the right number of attempts for your skill. No source in this manual's resource library publishes one, and the calculator ships with no default for it on purpose: you enter the number and it tells you what that costs. What the research does support is that practice needs a target and feedback to be worth anything, and that spacing attempts tends to beat massing them, which is the next section. The number itself is yours, and your own recorded minutes from After the workshop: what happened and what to change are the best source you will ever have for it.

One more thing the arithmetic tells you: how many people are standing around at any moment. That is participants minus stations, and it is the number that decides whether section 5 is a nicety or the main problem in your session.

4. Where you stand, and what you say

During a practice block you are the feedback. Where you put yourself decides who gets any.

Position

Decide this in advance and write it on the sheet. Three patterns:

  • Circulating. A loop of the room, in a fixed order, so that everybody gets the same amount of you. Without a fixed order you will spend the block with whoever talks.
  • Anchored at the hard station. If one station has the thing that goes wrong, stand there. Say out loud that you are doing it, so the others know where to find you.
  • Stationary with a queue. For a step that needs your hands, people bring their work to you. Works for small groups and produces a queue, which is dead time unless the queue has something to do.

With a helper, split the room explicitly and tell everyone who covers which half. Without one, circulating is usually the right default, and your loop should take less time than one attempt so that nobody waits a whole attempt for a word.

What you say to somebody who has it wrong

Write these in advance, in the errors sheet of your demonstration and practice sheets. One line per likely error. Writing them in advance does two things: it stops you inventing a different explanation for each person, and it makes you notice that half your corrections are the same two sentences.

A workable form has three parts and takes about eight seconds: name what you see, name the cause, hand back the next attempt. "The seam is opening. The skin is not tight before you set it down. Do one more and stop when you feel it tighten." What to avoid: taking the work out of their hands and doing it for them, which feels helpful and removes the attempt; and a general praise that names nothing, which is friendly and carries no information.

When to let it go wrong

Some errors teach more when they happen than when they are prevented. A loaf that collapses because the skin was slack is a better lesson than a warning about slack skin. Others ruin the attempt, waste material or are unsafe, and those you prevent. The errors sheet has a column for this decision, with three answers: yes it teaches, no step in, depends on the attempt. Ask the authority Anything with a safety dimension is outside this manual's scope: the rule that applies comes from your venue, your insurer, your employer and whoever has authority over them, and it is worth finding before the session rather than during it.

5. The people who are waiting

If you have more people than stations, somebody is waiting, and the waiting is a large fraction of your session. Six people and three stations means half the room is idle at any moment. Over a twenty-minute block, that is sixty person-minutes.

"Watch" is not an answer. Watching without a task is where phones come out. What works is a specific job with an output:

  • Watch for one named thing and report it. "Watch their hand angle and tell them what you saw before you swap." This is useful for the watcher, useful for the doer, and turns the swap into a feedback moment that costs you nothing.
  • Prepare for your own attempt. Measure, lay out, choose your materials, write your plan. Real work that would otherwise eat into the attempt.
  • Talk your partner through it. The watcher narrates while the doer works. This is step three of the four-step sequence in Showing someone how, so they can see it, used as a pairing, and it surfaces misunderstandings loudly.
  • Record on a sheet. If the session has a record to keep, the waiting person keeps it for the pair.

Whichever you choose, say it out loud when the block starts and write it on the run sheet. The rule that makes this work is that the waiting job has an output somebody will ask for.

6. Spacing, varying and the evidence behind them Go deeper

Two practice manipulations have enough evidence behind them to be worth building into a session, and it is worth knowing how strong that evidence is rated.

Dunlosky and colleagues' 2013 review for Psychological Science in the Public Interest, Improving Students' Learning With Effective Learning Techniques, rates ten study techniques by utility. Two come out high utility: practice testing and distributed practice, because they benefit learners of different ages and abilities and boost performance across many criterion tasks and in educational contexts. Three are moderate utility: elaborative interrogation, self-explanation and interleaved practice, held back because the evidence is more limited and they have not been adequately evaluated in educational contexts. Five are low utility: summarization, highlighting, the keyword mnemonic, imagery use for text learning, and rereading.

Physical principle Note what that review is about: study techniques, largely tested on learning material rather than on acquiring a physical skill, and in educational settings over weeks. The two high-utility findings point in a useful direction for a session, and they are not measurements of a two-hour workshop.

The Bjork Learning and Forgetting Lab at UCLA, on its research pages, gives the term for the family: R. A. Bjork named difficult but effective training conditions "desirable difficulties" in 1994. The manipulations the page names are spacing rather than massing repetitions, testing rather than restudying, varying the conditions of practice rather than keeping them constant, interleaving, generation, and perceptual disfluency, which it describes as possibly a desirable difficulty.

What fits in two hours

  • Space the attempts. Two attempts now and two later beats four in a row, and it costs nothing except a second block on the run sheet. This is the cheapest available improvement to most sessions.
  • Vary one condition on the last attempt. A different material, a different starting state, a different tool. People find this harder and that is the point; the discomfort is the mechanism, not a sign the session is failing.
  • Make them retrieve rather than reread. Before the second block, ask them to say the steps from memory rather than showing them again. This is practice testing, the other high-utility technique, used as a warm-up.

What does not fit: anything that needs weeks. Spacing across days is stronger than spacing across an hour, and if your people come back, two short sessions a week apart will likely do more than one long one. That is a scheduling decision rather than a teaching one, and it is often not yours to make.

7. When there is only one of the thing Go deeper

One machine, one patient simulator, one van, twelve people. This is common and it has no good solution, only less bad ones.

  • Shrink the attempt. Find the twenty-second part of the task that matters most and let everybody do that part, rather than three people doing the whole thing.
  • Split the task across people. One sets up, one performs, one checks, then rotate. Everybody touches the machine, and each role is a real job.
  • Simulate the rest. A cardboard mock-up, a printed screen, a dummy assembly. It feels unserious and it gives twelve people a rehearsal of the sequence, which is most of what the first attempt teaches.
  • Practice in pairs with a verbal attempt. One talks the other through the whole thing from memory. Weaker than doing it, stronger than watching.
  • Change the group size. The honest option, and sometimes the right one. Six people with real attempts learn more than twelve people watching, and the person who booked the session may prefer two sessions once you show them the arithmetic.

The arithmetic is the part to bring to that conversation. "Twelve people, one machine, ninety minutes, and a five-minute attempt means seven people get one go and five get none" is a sentence that changes decisions, and the practice time calculator produces it in a minute.

8. See it See it

Fictional example

Priya's practice arithmetic. Ten people, five benches, two hours at the community kitchen, one helper (Ann).

One attempt: shape one round loaf and stand it on the bench. Priya times herself: 90 seconds. She assumes a beginner takes three minutes, which is her own assumption based on watching her sister try it once.

The arithmetic: she wants three attempts each. Thirty attempts in all. With five benches, a twenty-five minute block gives 125 station minutes, so just over four minutes per attempt including changeover. Changeover is about a minute, since the next person needs a floured bench and a new piece of dough. That leaves about three minutes of hands on the work per attempt, which matches her assumed beginner time with nothing to spare.

What she changed: two blocks of fifteen minutes instead of one block of twenty-five, spaced either side of a second demonstration. Same total time, spaced attempts, and the second block starts with everybody saying the steps from memory rather than watching her again.

Waiting: five people are at benches and five are not. The waiting five watch their partner's hand angle and say one sentence about it before they swap. Priya writes that instruction on the run sheet so she says it the same way both times.

Where she stands: a fixed loop of the five benches, about two minutes per circuit, with Ann anchored at the bench nearest the door where the two people with the least experience are working.

What she says to a collapsed loaf: written in advance. "The skin is slack. You stopped dragging before it tightened. One more, and stop when it feels like a drum."

Open, and who settles it: whether the kitchen's dough will tolerate being reshaped three times, which changes how much dough she needs. The kitchen manager and a test batch settle that, and the answer changes her materials count.

9. Practice Practice

Minimum: one practice row per objective, with an attempt defined and a waiting job written. Time: about 40 minutes, plus the time to do one attempt yourself with a stopwatch. Materials: the practice design sheet in your demonstration and practice sheets, and a timer.

  1. Time one attempt yourself. Write the figure down. Then write your assumption about how long a beginner takes, and label it as an assumption.
  2. Put the numbers in the calculator. Block length, stations, people, attempts, changeover. Read off the minutes per attempt and the number waiting.
  3. Adjust until the minutes per attempt match your assumed beginner time. Change the attempts, the block length or the attempt itself. Write down which you changed.
  4. Split one block into two if you can. Same total minutes, spaced apart, with a retrieval question at the start of the second.
  5. Write the waiting job and the three sentences. The waiting job with its output, and one correction sentence for each of your three most likely errors.
Go deeper

Design the varied condition for the last attempt. Take one thing that will differ when people do this at home or at their own desk: a different material, a worse tool, a different starting state, no instructions in front of them. Make the final attempt happen under that condition and tell the room why you are doing it. Expect it to go worse than the earlier attempts, and say so in advance, so that nobody reads the difficulty as failure.

10. Your session Your session

11. Check your work Check your work

Criteria

  • Can you say what one attempt is in a single sentence, with a visible end?
  • Have you run the arithmetic rather than estimating the number of attempts?
  • Is the minutes-per-attempt figure larger than your assumed beginner time?
  • Is your position during each block written down?
  • Does every waiting person have a job with an output?

Worked example

Priya's attempt is one sentence and ends with a loaf standing on a bench. She ran the arithmetic and found three minutes of hands-on time against an assumed three-minute beginner attempt, which is tight and which she has written down as tight rather than as comfortable. Her position is a two-minute fixed loop, and Ann's is anchored. The waiting job has an output: one sentence about the partner's hand angle. Five criteria met, with the caveat that her beginner-time assumption is from watching one person, and the first run of the session is what will correct it.

Common mistakes

  • An attempt with no visible end. Without one, there is nothing to give feedback on and nothing to check.
  • Guessing the number of attempts. The arithmetic takes two minutes and is usually unkind.
  • Using your own speed as the planning figure. You are the fastest person in the room by a wide margin.
  • Leaving the waiting half with nothing. It is half your room and half your minutes.
  • Taking the work out of somebody's hands. It feels like helping and it removes the attempt you spent the session arranging.
  • One long block rather than two short ones. The split costs nothing and spacing has real support behind it.

What is still unresolved

This chapter does not tell you whether the practice worked: that is Checks for understanding: finding out whether it landed, and the check usually sits immediately after the block. It does not price the block against the rest of the session, which is Workshop timing: minutes on paper and minutes in the room. How many stations you can physically fit is Setting up a room people can actually work in and the room plan. And what people retain a week later is largely outside what a session controls, which Did the training work? Finding out afterward, and changing the session is honest about.

12. Knowledge check and scenario

What is the difference between practice and repetition?
Practice has a target and feedback. The person knows what they are trying to produce and something tells them whether they produced it. Repetition without those two produces many copies of whatever the person did first, and it lets an error become a habit, which takes longer to undo than it would have taken to prevent.
Six people, three stations, a twenty-minute block, two attempts each. How long is one attempt?
Sixty station minutes divided by twelve attempts is five minutes per attempt including changeover. Subtract the changeover, say a minute, and each attempt is four minutes of hands on the work. Three people are waiting at any moment, which over the block is sixty person-minutes that need a job.
Why does the practice time calculator have no default for attempts per person?
Because no source in the manual's resource library publishes a correct number of repetitions for an arbitrary skill, and a default would be read as a recommendation. The calculator takes your number and tells you what it costs in minutes, which is the part arithmetic can settle. The number itself comes from your own judgment and, after the first run, from your own recorded minutes.
(Go deeper) How strong is the evidence for spacing attempts?
Distributed practice is one of two techniques rated high utility in Dunlosky and colleagues' 2013 review, on the grounds that it benefits learners of different ages and abilities and boosts performance across many criterion tasks and in educational contexts. The review is about study techniques, largely tested on learning material rather than physical skills, so it supports splitting a block in two rather than predicting a result for your session.
Your arithmetic says each person gets two and a half minutes of hands-on time, and you think a beginner needs five. The session length is fixed and so is the room. What do you change?
Usually the strongest move. A smaller attempt with a visible end gives everybody a complete go and something to get feedback on, and you can add the rest of the task as a second performance if time allows. It also tends to improve the teaching, because a smaller attempt forces you to name which part of the task actually matters.
Defensible, and it is a real trade: one complete attempt beats three truncated ones, and it costs you the spacing and the chance to improve between goes. Take this where the task resists being subdivided. If you do, make the single attempt count by putting your feedback where it lands before the end.
This is what happens by default, and the cost falls unevenly: the fast finish, the slow stop halfway with something unfinished in front of them, and the people who most needed the practice get the least. If you cannot change the attempt or the count, change the group size or the session length, and use the arithmetic to make that case.

Checklist

Records your learning only; it is not a qualification.