Writing learning objectives: what they will be able to do
Three to five things a person will be seen doing, and a list of everything you cut to get there. This is the part of planning that decides what the practice and the checks can even be.
- Start here: the essentials
- 1. From what you know to what they do
- 2. Verbs you could film
- 3. Cutting what does not serve the performance
- 4. How many a session holds
- 5. Bloom's taxonomy, used as a sorting tool
- 6. Breaking a performance into component skills
- 7. When somebody else wrote the objectives
- 8. See it
- 9. Practice
- 10. Your session
- 11. Check your work
- 12. Knowledge check and scenario
Start here Essentials
You know more about your subject than fits in the time. This chapter turns the part that fits into three to five things a person will be seen doing, and parks the rest somewhere you can find it again.
- List everything you could teach about the subject. Fast and messy, twenty items if they come (section 1).
- Rewrite each as something a person would be seen doing. Some will not survive the rewrite, which is the test working (section 2).
- Delete any your room, your time or your materials cannot support. Be literal about this (section 3).
- Keep three to five and put the rest on a not-today list. Write the list down; do not just drop them (section 4).
Minimum time: about 45 minutes. Done when: three to five rows on the objectives sheet of your session plan, each starting with a verb you could film, and a not-today list holding everything else.
1. From what you know to what they do Understand
The gap this chapter crosses is between two kinds of list. One is a list of topics: the things you know about, the headings you would use if you were writing a book. The other is a list of performances: the things a person will do, with their hands or their mouth or their screen, by the end of the session.
Topic lists are easy to write and they plan nothing. "Dough hydration", "scoring", "oven spring" are three real subjects, and none of them tells you what happens in the room, how long it takes or how you would know it worked. Performance lists are harder to write and they plan everything downstream: the practice is people doing the thing on the list, the check is you watching them, the materials are whatever the doing needs, and the cut list is whatever is left over.
Carnegie Mellon's page on learning objectives gives the completion prompt and one test worth memorizing: what would they do differently? Convention If you cannot answer that question for an item on your list, the item is a topic.
Indiana University's account of backward course design, adapted from Wiggins and McTighe, puts the three stages in the order that keeps you honest: state the result, decide what evidence would show it, then work out what people need to do and only then choose content. Most people plan in the other direction, which is why the evidence step so often gets invented at the end or skipped.
2. Verbs you could film
The quickest working test for an objective is the filming test. Could you point a camera at a person and see whether they did it? "Understand", "appreciate", "be aware of", "know about" and "be familiar with" fail, because there is nothing for the camera. Carnegie Mellon's page flags three of these by name: understand X, obtain a working knowledge of X, gain an appreciation for X.
Here is the rewrite in both directions, so you can see what is lost and gained.
| Topic, as it comes out of your head | The question to ask | Performance you could film |
|---|---|---|
| Dough hydration | What would somebody do with that? | Feel two doughs and say which will spread, before shaping either |
| The new intake screen | What do they do on Monday? | Enter a client with no insurance, without asking for help |
| Pivot tables | Which actual task? | Build a pivot table that counts orders by month from a flat list |
| Reading a utility bill | What do they point at? | Point to the line on their own bill that changed most this year, and say what it is |
| Safety around the band saw | Which behavior, specifically? | Set the guard and check the stance before starting a cut, three times in a row |
Two refinements make these stronger. Add the condition, which is what they will have when they do it: "with the tools they already own", "without the handout", "from a flat list they have not seen before". And add the standard where there is one that matters: "that holds its shape standing on the bench" says more than "a good loaf", and it is something two people would agree on when they looked.
One honest exception. Some sessions are about recognition rather than production: being able to notice that a thing is wrong and call someone. That is still filmable. "Spot the three items on this form that should stop you processing it" is a performance; "be aware of the warning signs" is not.
3. Cutting what does not serve the performance
This is the part that hurts, and the part that makes the session possible. Every item on your list is interesting to you, which is why you know it, and the amount of time you have is fixed.
Three cuts, in this order:
Cut what the room cannot support
Be literal. If the performance needs a machine and the room has one machine and twelve people, twelve people are not going to practice the performance in ninety minutes. If it needs dough that has risen for four hours and the session is two hours long, somebody else makes the dough or the performance changes. This cut is arithmetic, not judgment, and the timing calculators do most of it.
Cut what does not serve the performances you kept
For each remaining item, ask whether a person could do the performance without it. Hydration theory is fascinating and somebody can shape a round loaf without it. That does not make it worthless; it makes it not-today. The test is strict on purpose, because the alternative is a session that covers everything and practices nothing.
Cut what they can get elsewhere more cheaply
Anything that is a reference rather than a skill belongs on paper. Temperatures, conversion tables, the order of fields on a form, the phone number for support. Put it in the handout, where it will be read at the moment of need rather than at ten past ten on a Saturday. Slides, handouts and materials: what you give them and when is about making that handout worth keeping.
Cutting is not the same as deciding something is unimportant, and this is worth saying out loud in the room. "We are not covering starter maintenance today, and here is where to read about it" treats people as adults and heads off the question. What this chapter cannot tell you is which three of your five candidates matter most to your particular group; that depends on what they can already do, which is Finding out what the room already knows, and on what they will go back to, which only they know.
Keep the list
Write what you cut in the "in or out" column of the objectives sheet, marked not today, rather than deleting it. Three reasons. You will be tempted to put things back the night before, and a list you can look at is easier to leave alone than a vague memory. When somebody asks about it in the room, you can say where it would go. And when you run the session a second time and something turns out to be missing, the list is where you look first.
4. How many a session holds
Three to five is the usual answer for a session of one to three hours, and the reason is arithmetic rather than theory. Each performance wants a demonstration, a practice block and a check. If a practice block is ten minutes and a check is three, then each performance costs the best part of twenty minutes before you have said anything, and a ninety-minute session with an opening and a closing has perhaps sixty-five minutes of working time in it.
Convention Three to five is a convention drawn from that arithmetic, not a published figure, and no source in this manual's resource library gives a correct number. Work out your own with the session budget calculator: put your candidate performances in as practice blocks and checks, and see what is left for teaching.
Two patterns that work when the arithmetic is tight:
- One deep, two shallow. One performance gets real practice with several attempts; the others get a demonstration and a show-me check. Honest, and better than four performances that each get four minutes.
- One performance, three conditions. Rather than three different things, the same thing under three different conditions, which is a form of varied practice that Designing the part where they do it comes back to.
5. Bloom's taxonomy, used as a sorting tool Go deeper
Somebody will suggest you write objectives using Bloom's taxonomy. It is worth knowing what it is and what it is for.
The University of Arkansas's page on using Bloom's taxonomy to write effective learning objectives (dated July 26, 2022) gives the six revised levels: Remembering, Understanding, Applying, Analyzing, Evaluating and Creating. It notes that Benjamin Bloom proposed the taxonomy in 1956 and that the terminology has been updated since.
| Level | What it describes | In a practical session, it looks like |
|---|---|---|
| Remembering | Recalling facts and basic concepts | Naming the parts of the tool before using them |
| Understanding | Explaining ideas or concepts | Saying why the dough spread, in their own words |
| Applying | Using information in a new situation | Shaping a loaf from dough they did not mix |
| Analyzing | Drawing connections between ideas | Comparing two failed loaves and saying what differed |
| Evaluating | Justifying a decision or position | Choosing between two methods for their own kitchen and defending it |
| Creating | Producing new or original work | Adapting the method to a dough the session did not cover |
Two warnings, both from that same page. Verb charts disagree with each other, and the level depends on the activity rather than on the verb: "analyze" in an objective can describe a mechanical sorting task, and "describe" can require real analysis. And it advises matching the level to the learners rather than stepping through every level in turn.
Convention So use it as a sorting tool: once your performances are written, look at where they sit and notice if they are all at one level. A session entirely at Remembering is a session that could have been a handout. A session entirely at Creating probably assumes more than your group has. One or two levels is what most short sessions live at, and that is not a failure.
6. Breaking a performance into component skills Go deeper
Sometimes a single performance turns out to be four. "Shape a round loaf" contains flouring the bench correctly, handling the dough without tearing it, the shaping movement itself, and judging when it has enough tension. A person can fail at any of those and the loaf fails the same way.
Carnegie Mellon's objectives page instructs breaking complex skills into their component skills, and its learning principles page says mastery requires three things together: the component skills, practice integrating them, and knowing when to apply what. That third part is the one that gets forgotten in short sessions, and it is the reason a person who can perform every step in order can still fail when the dough behaves differently.
What to do with that in two hours:
- Find the component that fails most. From your own experience or from asking somebody who learned recently. Practice that one separately, on its own, before the whole performance.
- Then practice the whole thing. Component practice alone leaves people able to do four things and not the thing.
- Vary one condition at the end. A slightly wetter dough, a different form, a machine with the setting moved. That is the beginning of knowing when to apply what, and it is uncomfortable in a good way.
7. When somebody else wrote the objectives Go deeper
Often you are handed objectives. They came from a manager, a committee, a funding application or last year's version of the session, and some of them are unmeasurable.
Do not throw them out, and do not pretend they are fine. Write your own version alongside, and take both to whoever owns them with a specific question: "I think this one means that people will be able to do X by the end. Is that what you meant?" That question is easy to answer and it is not a challenge. It produces one of three results: they agree, and you now have a measurable version with their blessing; they meant something different, which you have found out before the session rather than after; or they meant nothing in particular, in which case your version stands.
Two cases that need different handling. If the objective is really a message the organization wants delivered, say so in the plan and give it two minutes rather than building practice around it. And if the objective is a compliance requirement with specific wording, keep the wording and add your own measurable version underneath, because the wording may be doing a job that has nothing to do with teaching.
8. See it See it
Marisol's inherited objectives. Marisol Vance has three hours, twenty-four staff and four objectives written by her manager. Two are measurable and two are not.
As written: (1) Understand the importance of accurate data entry. (2) Be able to build a pivot table from a flat list. (3) Gain confidence with formulas. (4) Be able to write a formula that pulls a figure from another sheet.
Her rewrite of 1: "Spot the three kinds of entry error that break a pivot table, in a sheet they have not seen." That is filmable, and it serves objective 2 rather than competing with it.
Her rewrite of 3: she could not write one. "Confidence" is a feeling, and a feeling is not a performance. She brings it to her manager with the question above, and what her manager actually wants turns out to be "people should stop emailing me to ask", which rewrites as "find the answer in the built-in help before asking a colleague".
Known: twenty-four people, three hours, laptops, at least four people who can already do objective 4.
Assumed: that two pivot-table attempts each is possible in the time. Marisol's assumption, and the practice time calculator is where she tests it. On these assumptions four objectives is potentially one too many, and the one she would drop is the rewritten objective 3.
Open, and who settles it: whether her manager accepts the rewrites. Her manager settles that, this week, before the materials are printed.
- Carnegie Mellon on learning objectives: the completion prompt, the three vague phrasings to avoid, and the instruction to break complex skills into components.
- University of Arkansas on Bloom's taxonomy: the six revised levels with definitions, plus the warning that verb charts disagree and the level depends on the activity.
9. Practice Practice
Minimum: three performances written as filmable sentences, and a not-today list. Time: about 45 minutes. Materials: the objectives sheet in your session plan, or paper.
- Brain-dump the topics. Ten minutes, no editing. Write every heading you could teach under.
- Rewrite each as a performance. Finish "one person will be able to" for each. Mark the ones that resist the rewrite; they are usually reference material rather than skills.
- Apply the three cuts. What the room cannot support, what the kept performances do not need, what belongs on paper.
- Rank what is left and keep three to five. Put each in the objectives sheet with a level, and put the rest in the same sheet marked not today.
- Write the observation for each. One line per performance: what you would see. These become your checks in Checks for understanding: finding out whether it landed.
Take your hardest performance and break it into component skills. Write each component as its own filmable sentence, then decide which single component fails most often and design a two-minute practice for that one alone. You are not adding an objective; you are adding a rehearsal inside an existing one. Then write one varied condition for the end of the block, so that people meet the thing in a slightly different state than they practiced it in.
10. Your session Your session
11. Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- Does each objective start with a verb you could point a camera at?
- Does each one name the condition: with what, from what, with or without help?
- Could somebody else use your objective to judge whether a given person had met it?
- Can every objective be practiced in the room you have, with the materials you will have?
- Is there a written not-today list, with the things you cut on it?
Worked example
Marisol's rewritten set: spot three kinds of entry error in an unseen sheet; build a pivot table that counts orders by month from a flat list; write a formula that pulls a figure from another sheet; find the answer in the built-in help before asking a colleague. All four are filmable and three name their condition. The fourth is the weakest, because "before asking a colleague" describes behavior once the session is over rather than in it, which Did the training work? Finding out afterward, and changing the session deals with. Her room supports all four. Her not-today list has six items, inherited from the brain dump.
Common mistakes
- Keeping the topic list and calling it objectives. If a line could be a chapter heading, it is a topic.
- Writing eight objectives for ninety minutes. Each one wants a demonstration, practice and a check. Eight is a day.
- Objectives that only you could judge. "Shape it properly" is not a standard two people would agree on.
- Climbing the taxonomy because it exists. One or two levels is what a short session lives at.
- Silently dropping what you cut. Say it out loud in the room and point at where to read about it.
What is still unresolved
This chapter does not put the objectives in an order or give them minutes; that is Structuring a session: the run sheet and Workshop timing: minutes on paper and minutes in the room. It does not tell you how to show the thing, which is Showing someone how, so they can see it, nor how many attempts a person needs, which is a question nobody can answer in general and which Designing the part where they do it turns into arithmetic you can do.