Materials, slides and handouts
The room and the day

Slides, handouts and materials: what you give them and when

Every sheet of paper and every slide has a job. This chapter names the job, counts the quantities with spares, and drafts the one thing that leaves the room with each person and still makes sense in a month.

Start here Essentials

One thing leaves the room with each person. Everything else on the materials list exists to support what happens in the room. Decide which is which.

  1. Decide the one thing each person takes home. One, not a folder (section 2).
  2. Write it as a job aid they could use with the session forgotten. A page, used at the bench (section 2).
  3. Count your materials and add spares. The materials calculator turns a count into packs (section 4).
  4. Decide what is handed out before, during and after, and why. The timing changes what people do with it (section 5).

Minimum time: about 45 minutes, most of it on the job aid. Done when: the materials sheet in Materials and room check has quantities and spares, and one take-home job aid is drafted that makes sense to somebody who was not there.

1. Every piece of paper has a job Understand

Session materials accumulate without anybody deciding. A slide deck because that is what you make, a handout because people expect one, a copy of the slides because somebody asked, a feedback form because the organization has one. Each costs printing, attention and minutes, and most of them have no stated job.

There are four jobs, and a piece of paper should be doing one of them:

JobWhat it isWhen it is usedCommon failure
Carry the session homeA job aid: the steps, compressed, usable at the benchNext week, at the moment of doingReplaced by a copy of the slides, which is unusable at a bench
Hold the detail you cutReference: tables, numbers, settings, where to buyLater, when a specific question arisesRead aloud during the session, which wastes the room's time
Support an activity in the roomA worksheet, a sample, a form to mark upDuring one segmentHanded out early, so people read it while you demonstrate
Direct attention during a demonstrationA slide, a diagram, a projected close-upIn the moment, while something is happeningCovered in words that compete with what you are saying

Anything that is not doing one of those four is a candidate for deletion, and the most common deletion is "a copy of the slides as a handout", which does none of them. Slides are built to be seen for thirty seconds from eight feet away while somebody talks over them. Printed six to a page, they are a record of a performance rather than a usable document.

2. The one thing that leaves with them

Here is the test for a job aid: could somebody use it next Tuesday, at the thing, having forgotten your session entirely? That means it is usable without the memory of you, which rules out "key takeaways", bullet points of principles and anything written as a reminder of a conversation.

What makes a job aid work:

  • It is organized by the order of doing, not by the order of teaching. Step one is the first thing you touch, not the first thing you learned.
  • It names the failure next to the step. "Drag until the skin feels tight. If the seam opens in the oven, it was not tight enough."
  • It fits where the work happens. One side of one page for a bench. A card for a pocket. A screenshot sequence for a screen task.
  • It survives being wet, floury or greasy, if that is the environment. Card, or a plastic sleeve, or a note that it is designed to be printed again.
  • It names the thing to do first. People come back to a job aid when they are stuck, and the first line should answer the most common version of stuck.

Writing one takes about an hour and it is the most durable thing you will produce, because it outlives the session by years and travels to people who were not there. If your time is limited, build the job aid before you build the slides.

One practical note on who else uses it: a job aid that is good enough gets passed to colleagues who did not come. That is a feature, and it is worth writing so that it is usable by a stranger: put the date on it, and leave off anything that depends on being in the room when it was handed out.

3. Slides, and the argument about words on them

If you use slides, the question that will come up is how much text to put on them, and the advice points in two directions.

On one side, the redundancy principle. The University of Washington School of Medicine's summary of principles for teaching with multimedia lists it among Mayer's principles: use animation with narration rather than narration plus identical on-screen text. The reasoning is that reading and listening to the same words at once competes for the same channel.

On the other side, a finding in the paper that debunked the attention-span claim. Bradbury's 2016 article in Advances in Physiology Education reports, citing Scerbo and colleagues, that written cues are recorded more frequently and better retained than statements preceded by spoken cues, and concludes that key points should be presented in writing as well as spoken.

And there is a third consideration that settles part of it. The W3C's event accessibility checklist instructs speakers to describe all relevant visual information, and for slides it asks for limited text per slide, text and important visuals big enough to read from the back, an easy-to-read font face, sufficient luminance contrast, care with motion and animation, and no blinking or flashing. A person who cannot see the slide needs the content spoken; a person who cannot hear it well needs the content written.

Limits

These pull in different directions and this manual is not going to pretend they resolve neatly. The redundancy principle is about narration plus identical on-screen text in a multimedia lesson; the written-cue finding is about what people record and retain from a lecture; the access instruction is about reaching people who cannot use one channel. What follows is a default rather than a rule, and your subject may push it either way.

The default this manual uses: key points in writing on the slide and also spoken, in your own words rather than read aloud verbatim; detail in the handout rather than on the slide; nothing read aloud word for word from a slide; and anything visual described out loud as you show it. That satisfies the written-cue finding for the points that matter, avoids the word-for-word duplication the redundancy principle warns about, and keeps the session usable by somebody who cannot see the screen.

A practical floor, from the same W3C list: text big enough to read from the back of the room, which you check by standing at the back rather than by picking a font size.

4. Counting materials, with spares

The materials sheet in Materials and room check takes one row per item, with per-person, people, spares and total. The materials calculator turns that into packs to buy and units left over.

What people get wrong:

  • Counting for the headcount rather than for the attempts. If each person makes three attempts and each attempt consumes material, you need three per person, not one.
  • Forgetting your own demonstration. You use material too, often twice, and the second demonstration uses it again.
  • Forgetting the spare set for the repeat. If you might demonstrate again for latecomers or for a table that could not see, that set has to exist.
  • No spares for failures. First attempts fail, and a failed attempt that consumes material needs a replacement or the person stops.
  • Spares as a percentage with no thought. The spare percentage is your choice and the calculator has no default for it. For a cheap consumable, a generous number costs little; for something expensive, count the specific failures you expect instead.

Three rows that belong on every materials sheet and are usually missing: the thing you demonstrate with, a spare set for the second demonstration, and whatever the waiting people use for their waiting job from Designing the part where they do it.

The sheet also has three size columns, for anything that stands on the floor: width, depth and the standing room in front. Filling those lets the room plan place a bench or a cart at its real size, with a person working at it.

5. When to hand things out

Timing changes what a document does.

WhenWhat it is good forWhat it costs
Before the session, by emailTelling people what to bring; a pre-read that frees the room's timeMany will not read it; plan for the version where half have not
On arrival, on the seatSomething people fill in during the sessionPeople read it while you are talking
At the start of the segment that uses itWorksheets, samples, anything to mark upA minute of handing out, which belongs on the run sheet
At the endThe job aid, the reference, anything to take awayNothing, if the closing has minutes for it
Emailed afterwardsA second copy, the answer to the question you could not answerNeeds a list of addresses, which needs to be collected

The rule that follows: anything you want people to attend to in the room arrives at the moment it is used, and anything you want people to keep arrives at the end. The common failure is handing out the full pack at the start, which guarantees that somebody is reading page four while you demonstrate.

One exception worth making deliberately: if people are anxious about keeping up, saying "there is a handout with all of this, so you do not need to write it down" at the start, without handing it out, removes the note-taking pressure and keeps the attention.

6. Mayer's principles and what they were tested on Go deeper

The University of Washington page groups Mayer's principles under three goals.

  • Reduce extraneous processing: coherence (exclude extraneous material), signaling (highlight the main ideas), redundancy (animation with narration rather than narration plus identical on-screen text), spatial contiguity (related words and pictures near each other), temporal contiguity (words and pictures together in time).
  • Manage essential processing: segmenting (learner-paced segments), pre-training (names and characteristics first), modality (narration rather than on-screen text with an animation).
  • Foster generative processing: personalization (conversational style), voice.

Physical principle The caveat the page itself supports: these were tested on narrated animations and multimedia lessons, not on a person at the front of a room with a tray of materials. Coherence transfers readily, since cutting decorative content costs nothing. Spatial and temporal contiguity transfer to a slide. Segmenting, in the sense of learner-paced parts, does not transfer to a live session, because you set the pace. Treat the list as a source of good questions rather than as findings about your room, and note that Showing someone how, so they can see it makes the same point about a live demonstration.

Coherence is the one worth acting on today. Decorative photographs, background templates with a logo on every slide, and a joke slide between sections are all extraneous material by that definition, and removing them takes ten minutes.

7. Formats people can adapt, and why PDF alone is a problem Go deeper

The W3C's event checklist is specific about handout formats. It asks for formats users can adapt, such as word processing, HTML or EPUB, and says to avoid providing material only in formats that users cannot adapt, including PDF and protected word processing documents. It also asks for alternative text on images, headings marked up as headings, and HTML material meeting the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines at least at level AA. It notes that some participants need large print or Braille.

The reason is practical rather than ideological. A person who needs larger text, a different font, a different color scheme, or a screen reader that follows a document's structure can do all of that with a word processing file or an HTML page, and often cannot with a PDF, particularly one made by exporting a slide deck.

What to do, cheaply: send the handout as the source document as well as the PDF; use real headings rather than large bold text; write alternative text for any image that carries information; and if somebody asks for large print, print it at the size they ask for rather than offering to zoom.

For the government's own entry point on authoring accessible presentation files, the GSA's Accessible Presentations page links authoring and testing guides and a checklist. Convention That page carries its own note that much of the linked guidance predates the Revised 508 Standards, so this manual cites it as the entry point and takes the concrete slide requirements from the W3C checklist instead. What applies to your event, and who is responsible, is in Access: what to ask, what to arrange, who decides.

8. See it See it

Fictional example

Dale's job aid. Dale Okonkwo teaches a ninety-minute faucet class at a hardware store. Eight people, eight practice faucets, no helper, taught four times.

His first version: a six-page printout of his slides, stapled. He stopped making it when he noticed nobody picked them up from the back table.

His current version: one side of one card, laminated, organized by the order of doing: turn off the supply, plug the drain, take off the handle, pull the cartridge, match it at the counter, reassemble. Each step has the failure next to it. "Plug the drain. If you skip this, the screw goes down it and the job becomes two jobs."

Known: eight people, eight stations, ninety minutes, a store that will print cards for him.

What he counts: eight practice faucets, one demonstration faucet, one spare for a second demonstration, eight cartridges plus four spares because two usually get cross-threaded, and twelve cards because some people take one for a neighbor.

Assumed, and whose assumption it is: that two cartridges per session get damaged. Dale's figure, from his own records across four sessions. Under that assumption four spares is comfortable; if a session is unusually rough it is two short.

When he hands things out: the card at the end, because handing it out earlier means people read it during the demonstration. The cartridge-matching reference goes out at the start of the segment that uses it.

What he says at the start: "Everything on the card at the end, so you do not need to write it down."

Open, and who settles it: whether the store will keep printing the cards. The store manager settles that, and Dale has the file so he can print them himself if the answer changes.

9. Practice Practice

Minimum: one job aid drafted and the materials sheet filled with spares. Time: about 45 minutes. Materials: the materials sheet in Materials and room check and the materials calculator.

  1. Write the job aid as a numbered sequence of doing. Not of teaching. One side of one page.
  2. Add the failure beside each step. What goes wrong if this step is skipped or done badly.
  3. Test it on somebody who was not there. Hand it over with no explanation and watch where they stop.
  4. Fill the materials sheet, including your demonstration set, the spare demonstration set and whatever the waiting people use.
  5. Run the materials calculator for the one item with the largest count, and write the packs and the leftovers into the sheet.
Go deeper

Take your slides and delete every slide that does not either show something happening or carry a key point in writing. Then stand at the back of the room, or as far from your screen as the back of the room will be, and read each remaining slide. Anything you cannot read goes up in size or comes off the slide into the handout. This exercise usually removes a third of a deck and takes twenty minutes.

10. Your session Your session

11. Check your work Check your work

Criteria

  • Could somebody use your job aid next week having forgotten the session?
  • Is it organized by the order of doing rather than the order of teaching?
  • Does every item on the materials sheet have a quantity that accounts for attempts, not just people?
  • Are your demonstration set and a spare demonstration set on the list?
  • Does each handout have a stated job and a stated moment of handing out?

Worked example

Dale's card is usable cold: it is a sequence of doing with failures beside the steps, on material that survives a workbench. His counts account for attempts and include both demonstration sets, with a spares figure derived from his own records rather than from a percentage. Each item has a moment: the card at the end, the reference at the segment that uses it. Five criteria met. What he has not done is test the card on somebody who was not there, which is the fastest way to find the step he has compressed.

Common mistakes

  • Slides printed as the handout. They do none of the four jobs.
  • A job aid organized by the teaching order. People use it in the order of doing.
  • Counting by headcount, not by attempts. Three attempts each means three sets each.
  • Reading the detail aloud. If a page can carry it, the page should.
  • Everything handed out at the start. Somebody is reading page four during the demonstration.
  • PDF only. Send the source document too, so people who need to change the text can.

What is still unresolved

This chapter does not say where the materials go in the room or whether people can reach them, which is Setting up a room people can actually work in and the room plan. It does not price the handing out, which belongs on the run sheet in Workshop timing: minutes on paper and minutes in the room. What to arrange for a participant who needs a different format, and who decides, is in Access: what to ask, what to arrange, who decides.

12. Knowledge check and scenario

Why is a printed copy of the slides a poor handout?
Because it does none of the four jobs. Slides are built to be seen briefly from a distance while somebody talks over them, so printed they are a record of a performance rather than a usable document. A job aid organized by the order of doing, with the failures named beside the steps, is what somebody can actually use at the bench next Tuesday.
Two sources disagree about words on slides. What does the manual do?
It shows both and states a default. The redundancy principle warns against narration plus identical on-screen text; a peer-reviewed paper reports that written cues are recorded more frequently and better retained than spoken ones, and concludes key points should be in writing as well as spoken; and the W3C checklist asks for limited text, readable size and spoken description of visual information. The default is key points written and spoken in your own words, detail in the handout, nothing read aloud verbatim.
What does counting materials by headcount miss?
The attempts. If each person makes three attempts and each attempt consumes material, the count is three per person. It also tends to miss your own demonstration set, the spare set for a second demonstration, the material for whatever the waiting people are doing, and spares for the attempts that fail, which on a first attempt is a reasonable number of them.
(Go deeper) Why does the W3C checklist ask for formats other than PDF?
Because a person who needs larger text, a different font or color scheme, or a screen reader that follows document structure can usually do that with a word processing file or an HTML page and often cannot with a PDF, particularly one exported from a slide deck. The checklist asks for formats users can adapt, alternative text on images, headings marked up as headings, and HTML material meeting WCAG at least at level AA.
You have an hour of preparation left and no job aid, but your slides are unfinished. What do you spend it on?
The job aid is the thing that outlives the session, travels to people who were not there, and is used at the moment of doing. Slides support a performance you will be present for; you can point at the real thing, or write on a board. If one of the two has to be unfinished, let it be the one you are standing next to.
The common choice, and it optimizes for the ninety minutes you are in the room rather than for the weeks afterwards. Finished slides and no job aid produce a session that looked organized and left nothing usable behind.
Understandable, and half an hour rarely produces a job aid worth keeping. If you do split, write the job aid first and stop when the hour is up, because a rough job aid is more useful than a polished slide.

Checklist

Records your learning only; it is not a qualification.