The shape of a session
Building the session

Structuring a session: the run sheet

A run sheet where every row says what the room is doing, not what you are saying. Segments, practice blocks and checks, in an order you can defend, with the opening and the closing written last.

Start here Essentials

This chapter turns your objectives into a list of segments. Write what the room is doing in each one. Leave the minutes until later.

  1. Write one line per segment naming what people will be doing. Not what you will be saying (section 1).
  2. Put a practice block against each performance on your objectives sheet. One block per performance, at minimum (section 2).
  3. Put a check after each practice block. A question or a show-me, before you move on (section 2).
  4. Write the opening and the closing last. They are the two that get cut, so write them when you know what is left (section 4).
  5. Read the list and cross out any segment where the room only listens for longer than you can justify. Say the justification out loud (section 2).

Minimum time: about 40 minutes. Done when: the run sheet in your session plan has a row per segment, every row names an action by the participants, and every objective has at least one practice block and one check against it.

1. A run sheet is a list of what the room does Understand

Most session plans are written in the first person: I will introduce myself, I will explain the background, I will demonstrate, I will take questions. That plan tells you what you are doing every minute and tells you nothing about what anybody else is doing, which is the thing that decides whether the session works.

The run sheet in this manual has two columns side by side for that reason: what you do and what they do. The second column is the one to fill first. When a row's second column reads "listen", you have found a segment to question. Sometimes listening is the right answer and you can say why: they are watching the demonstration, which is the thing they cannot do without. Often it is a default.

This is the same idea as backward design pushed one level down. Indiana University's page on backward course design states the sequence at the level of a whole course: result, evidence, what people need to do, then content and activities. Convention At the level of one session, the same order means you place the practice and the checks first and let the explaining fill the space between them, rather than placing the explaining first and hoping for room at the end.

That page also reports a general tendency worth knowing: lectures facilitate learning at the lower end of the taxonomy, while discussion, problem solving and writing tend to support higher-order processes. It is a statement about course design rather than about your two hours, and it points the same way as the column exercise.

2. Segments, and what a segment is for

A segment is a block of the session with one job and one mode. The mode is what the room is doing: watching, attempting, discussing, answering, writing, moving. The job is what the segment is there to achieve.

Five segment types cover most practical sessions:

SegmentWhat the room doesWhat it is forWhat goes wrong
OpeningHears what they will be able to do; answers one short questionSets the target and gets the room to speak onceBecomes introductions and housekeeping, and eats ten minutes
DemonstrationWatches, from somewhere they can seeShows the performance at a speed a beginner can followToo fast, too far away, too many steps merged
Practice blockAttempts the thing, a stated number of timesThe only part where anyone gets better at doing itShrinks to fit when earlier segments overrun
CheckAnswers at once, by hands, cards or a show-meTells you whether to move onReplaced by "any questions?", which checks nothing
ClosingWrites down the next thing they will doCarries the session out of the roomCut for time, so the session ends mid-sentence

Two rules make the list usable. Every performance on your objectives sheet gets at least one practice block and one check. And every check sits after the practice it is checking, because a check before practice measures your explanation rather than their ability.

The listening test

Go down the list and find every segment where the second column says "listen" or "watch". For each one, say out loud why the room cannot get this from a page. Good answers: they are watching hands do something a page cannot show; they are hearing a decision being made out loud; the thing is three minutes long and would be two pages written. Weak answers: it is background; it is context; they need to know it first. Convention Background that a page could carry belongs in the handout, which Slides, handouts and materials: what you give them and when is about.

3. Ordering the pieces

Once you have the segments, the order is mostly decided by three things.

What genuinely depends on what

Some orders are forced: you cannot shape dough before there is dough, and you cannot build a pivot table before the data is in one sheet. Write those dependencies down, because they are usually fewer than they feel. "You need to understand the theory first" is usually a preference rather than a dependency, and it is the preference that pushes practice to the end of the session where the time runs out.

What fails if it goes last

Anything that needs time to happen, dough resting, glue setting, a file downloading, goes early whether or not it is first in the logic. Anything the session cannot do without goes before the point where you might run out of time. In practice this means the most important practice block sits in the first two thirds of the session, not at the end.

What gives you information early

Put a check early, even a crude one. Finding out at minute fifteen that half the room is lost gives you seventy-five minutes to act. Finding out at minute eighty-five gives you a feeling.

A workable default shape for a single performance looks like this, and repeats:

  1. Show it. The demonstration, broken into visible steps.
  2. They attempt it. The practice block, with the number of attempts you planned.
  3. Check. A question or a show-me, answered by everyone at once.
  4. Act on the answer. Reteach the step that failed, or move on. This step has to exist on the sheet, or the check is decoration.
Limits

A shape is not a formula. This one assumes a skill with a visible performance and a room where people can attempt it; a session that is mostly a decision, a discussion or an announcement has a different shape, and Deciding whether a workshop is the right format is where to check which one you have. What no source in this manual's resource library supplies is a correct number of segments or a correct length for one, which the next section is about.

4. The opening and the closing, written last

Write these when the rest of the sheet exists, because they are shaped by what is in it and because they are the two segments that get squeezed.

The opening

An opening has three jobs and takes about five minutes. Say what people will be able to do by the end, in the words of your objectives, so that the target is shared. Say how the time is split, so that nobody spends the first hour wondering when they get to touch anything. And get the room to speak once, with the thirty-second check from Finding out what the room already knows, because the second time a room speaks is much easier than the first.

What an opening does not need: your biography, a slide of the agenda read aloud, an icebreaker unrelated to the subject, or housekeeping that could be on a card by the door. If people need to know where the restrooms are, say it in one sentence.

The closing

A closing has two jobs and takes about five minutes. The first is to get each person to write down the one thing they will do next, with a date if there is one. Writing it down matters more than it sounds: it converts a session into an intention that leaves the building. The second is to hand over the thing that carries the session home, which is usually a job aid rather than a copy of the slides.

If there is a feedback form, it goes here, and Did the training work? Finding out afterward, and changing the session explains what it does and does not measure before you write its questions.

5. The argument about segment length Go deeper

Somebody will tell you to change activity every ten or fifteen minutes, or that no segment should run past twenty. Here are the two sources behind those numbers, and they disagree.

The University of Connecticut's teaching center, on its page about active learning, states that attention often begins to decline after 10 to 15 minutes of lecture. That is a current page from a university teaching center, and it is where many people will have met the claim.

A peer-reviewed article in Advances in Physiology Education traced the claim and did not find support for it. Bradbury's 2016 paper, Attention span during lectures: 8 seconds, 10 minutes, or more?, reports that the literature is full of works propagating a 10 to 15 minute attention span, that note taking, which several of them used as a proxy, is not a good proxy for attention, and that the claim amounts to, in the paper's words, an unsubstantiated mantra. The same paper traces the famous eight-second figure to a study commissioned by Microsoft and reported in Time, and notes that the figure actually describes the average time a person spends on a web page before looking elsewhere.

The other number in circulation is a commercial convention. The Bob Pike Group's Train-the-Trainer Boot Camp page lists a 90-20-10 chunking rule among the things participants will discover. Convention The page gives no source for it. It is one company's convention, and this manual names it as that.

We are not going to pick a winner for you, because the two sources are not equivalent: one is a teaching center repeating a widely held claim, the other is a peer-reviewed review that went looking for the evidence behind it. What follows from that, practically:

  • Segment for a reason you can name. A check, a practice block, a change of posture, a thing that needs to happen now. Those are reasons. A clock is not.
  • Notice that long listening segments have a different problem. Whether or not attention declines on a schedule, a room that is listening is a room you are getting no information from, and that is reason enough to break it up.
  • Use your own recorded minutes. From the second run of a session, your own figures from After the workshop: what happened and what to change beat any convention.

Learning myths and other claims about teaching, and what their sources say sets this out in a table with the other claims this subject attracts.

6. Sessions longer than three hours Go deeper

Past about three hours, two things change. People need a real break, with food or at least a bathroom queue that is not a scramble, and the W3C's event accessibility checklist lists breaks in the schedule as an organizer's item rather than a nicety. And the session gains a structural problem the short one does not have: the material from the morning is cold by mid-afternoon.

Three moves that help:

  • Return to the morning's performance after lunch, briefly, as a second attempt rather than a recap. Spacing attempts is one of the few practice manipulations with solid evidence behind it, which Designing the part where they do it covers.
  • Put the hardest practice before lunch, not after. Rooms are slower after eating, and whatever is scheduled at 2 p.m. gets the worst of the day.
  • Plan the break as a segment with a time on it, including who announces the end. Breaks run over by default, and a fifteen-minute break that becomes twenty-five has eaten a practice block.

7. See it See it

Fictional example

Dale's second version of the faucet class. Dale Okonkwo teaches a ninety-minute class on fixing a dripping faucet at a hardware store. Eight people, each with their own practice faucet clamped to a bench, no helper. He has taught it four times and kept his minutes from the last one.

Known: ninety minutes, eight people, eight stations, one teacher, and his own recorded minutes from the fourth run.

His first version, as he taught it the first time: twenty minutes on types of faucet, twenty minutes demonstrating, thirty minutes practice, twenty minutes of questions.

What his records showed: the types segment ran to twenty-eight minutes and the practice to nineteen. Three people did not get the cartridge out.

His current run sheet, by what the room does: opening, five minutes, they answer a hands-up question about which faucet they have at home. Demonstration one, eight minutes, they watch the cartridge come out. Practice one, twenty minutes, they get the cartridge out, twice each. Check, three minutes, everyone holds up their cartridge, he counts. Demonstration two, six minutes. Practice two, twenty minutes. Check, three minutes. Closing, five minutes, they write down which faucet they will try at home and take the job aid.

What moved: faucet types went into the handout. Questions stopped being a segment and became something he takes during practice, when he is walking anyway.

Assumed: that twenty minutes gives eight people two attempts each with their own station. On his own figures that holds, and he checks it in the practice time calculator each time the group size changes.

Open, and who settles it: whether the store will let him start ten minutes earlier so the opening is not rushed. The store manager settles that.

8. Practice Practice

Minimum: one row per segment with the "what they do" column filled. Time: about 40 minutes. Materials: your objectives sheet and the run sheet in your session plan.

  1. Write the middle first. For each performance on your objectives sheet, add three rows: a demonstration, a practice block, a check.
  2. Fill the "what they do" column for every row. If a row's answer is "listen", write the justification in the same cell. If you cannot write one, mark the row for cutting.
  3. Order the rows. Forced dependencies first, then anything that needs time to happen, then put your most important practice in the first two thirds.
  4. Add an early check. Somewhere in the first quarter, so that being wrong about the room is survivable.
  5. Write the opening and the closing. Five minutes each, with the jobs listed above.
Go deeper

Read the sheet to somebody who was not there when you wrote it, column two only: "they answer a hands-up question, they watch, they attempt it twice, they hold up what they made." If the recitation sounds like a session, it is one. If it sounds like a list of things you will say, the second column is not finished. This takes four minutes and catches more than rereading it yourself.

9. Your session Your session

10. Check your work Check your work

Criteria

  • Does every row name an action by the participants, not only by you?
  • Does every objective have at least one practice block and one check against it?
  • Does each check sit after the practice it checks, and is there a row for acting on its answer?
  • Is there a check in the first quarter of the session?
  • Are the opening and the closing written, with a job each rather than a habit?

Worked example

Dale's sheet has eight rows and every one has an action in column two, including the opening. Both performances have a practice block and a check. The first check is at minute thirty-three, which is later than a quarter of the way in; he could move the hands-up question into a real check on something he taught, or add a small one after the first demonstration. His opening and closing each have a job. Seven criteria out of eight, with the early check as the gap.

Common mistakes

  • A plan written entirely in the first person. It reads well and tells you nothing about the room.
  • Practice at the end. It is the segment that gets eaten when earlier rows overrun, which they will.
  • "Any questions?" as the check. It samples the confident, and silence from it means nothing.
  • Segmenting to a clock. Change what the room is doing for a reason you can name.
  • No row for acting on a check. If the check comes back badly and the sheet has no slack, you will move on anyway.

What is still unresolved

This chapter does not put minutes on the rows, which is Workshop timing: minutes on paper and minutes in the room, and that chapter will send you back here to cut. It does not say how to build the demonstration rows, which is Showing someone how, so they can see it, nor what one attempt is inside a practice block, which is Designing the part where they do it.

11. Knowledge check and scenario

Why fill the "what they do" column before the "what you do" column?
Because it is the column that decides whether the session works, and because it exposes segments that exist by default. A plan written from your side reads smoothly and hides the fact that the room is listening for fifty minutes. Filling the room's column first forces each segment to justify itself in terms of what anybody other than you is doing.
Two sources disagree about segment length. What does the manual do with that?
It shows both. A university teaching center's active learning page states that attention often declines after 10 to 15 minutes of lecture; a peer-reviewed review traced that claim and found no support for it, calling it an unsubstantiated mantra, and traced the eight-second figure to the average time spent on a web page. The practical conclusion is to segment for a reason you can name rather than to a clock, and to use your own recorded minutes once you have them.
Why does a check belong in the first quarter of the session?
Because a check tells you what to do next, and that information is worth more the more time you have left. Finding out at minute fifteen that half the room is lost leaves you most of the session to act on it. The same finding at minute eighty-five is a note for next time.
(Go deeper) Where does the 90-20-10 rule come from?
It appears on a commercial training company's boot camp page as one of the things participants will discover. The page gives no source for it, so this manual treats it as one company's convention and names it as that, rather than as a research finding.
Your draft run sheet has forty minutes of you explaining before anybody touches anything. The explaining is genuinely useful background. What do you do?
The test is whether a page could carry it. Background usually can, and a handout is read at the moment of need rather than at ten past ten. Starting with a demonstration and an attempt also buys you information early: you find out what people actually struggle with, and some of the background becomes answerable in one sentence at the bench instead of in ten minutes at the front.
Better than forty unbroken minutes, and it leaves the session in the same shape: most of the time spent listening. Worth doing if the background genuinely has to be spoken, but ask the page test first, because three short talks still crowd out the practice.
This is the most common belief in the subject and it is usually a preference rather than a dependency. Ask what specifically a person cannot attempt without. Often it is two sentences, not forty minutes, and the rest is context that lands better after somebody has tried the thing and met the problem it explains.

Checklist

Records your learning only; it is not a qualification.