Deciding whether a workshop is the right format
A session is one way to teach something and often not the best one. The question is not whether workshops work. It is whether this one has a performance behind it that a room full of people can practice.
Start here Essentials
This chapter asks for one sentence and one decision. The sentence says what a person will be able to do afterwards. The decision is whether a session is the form that gets them there.
- Write what one person should be able to do. Write it as something you could watch them do, with a verb you could film (section 2).
- Say where they will do it and with what. At their own bench, on their own laptop, in their own kitchen, with the tools they have (section 2).
- Cross out anything in your subject that does not serve that sentence. Put it on a list you keep rather than deleting it (section 2).
- Decide whether they can practice it in the room you have. If they cannot, say what they will do in the room instead (section 3).
- Name the thing you will watch for. The one observation that would tell you it worked (section 2).
Minimum time: about 30 minutes with a blank page. Done when: you have one sentence beginning "After this, one person will be able to" that names something observable, and you can say what you would watch them do to see it.
1. What a session is, as a form Understand
Somebody asked you to teach something. Before you think about slides, think about what you have been handed: a room, a block of time, a group of people who will all be there at once, and a subject you know. Those four things are the form. They are expensive, and they buy a specific thing.
The room costs everyone their morning. Ten people at two hours each is twenty hours of other people's time, plus the travel, plus whatever they rearranged to come. That is the real price of a session, and it is paid whether or not anyone leaves able to do anything. Convention A document costs each reader the minutes they choose to spend on it, in the order they choose, at the moment they need it. A session costs all of them the same two hours at the same time.
What a session buys, and a document does not, is three things: people attempt the thing while someone who can do it is standing there; the person teaching finds out, in the room, what is going wrong; and the group sees each other's attempts. That is the whole list. Everything else a session is often used for, announcing a policy, walking through a slide deck, reading a procedure aloud, is a document being performed at people, and it is the most common reason a session leaves nobody able to do anything.
So the question this chapter asks is not whether workshops work. Plenty of them do. The question is narrower and more useful: does this one have a performance behind it that this room can practice? If it does, a session is the right form and the rest of this manual is about building it. If it does not, you are about to spend twenty hours of other people's time on a form that cannot deliver what you want, and there are cheaper ways to do the same job.
2. The performance test
Here is the test, and it is almost embarrassingly simple. Finish this sentence:
"After this session, one person will be able to ________."
Carnegie Mellon's teaching center uses the same completion prompt and adds the question that makes it bite: what would they do differently? Their page on writing learning objectives flags three ways of finishing the sentence that look fine and are not: "understand X", "obtain a working knowledge of X", and "gain an appreciation for X". Convention The problem with all three is not that they are vague in a literary sense. It is that there is nothing to watch, so there is nothing to practice and nothing to check, and afterwards there is no way to tell whether the session did anything.
Compare these two sentences about the same two hours:
| What people usually write | What it leaves you with | A version you could watch |
|---|---|---|
| Understand how our new intake system works | No practice to design, no check to write, no way to know afterwards | Enter a new client, including one with no insurance, without asking for help |
| Appreciate the importance of hand position in shaping | You will demonstrate, they will nod | Shape a round loaf that holds its shape standing on the bench |
| Gain a working knowledge of spreadsheet formulas | You will show formulas for three hours | Build a running total that updates when a row is inserted, and say why it broke when it does |
| Learn to read your utility bill | You will read a bill out loud at them | Point to the line on their own bill that changed most since last year, and say what it is |
The right-hand column is harder to write, and that is the point. It takes a decision out of the room and into the planning. Once the sentence exists you know what the practice is, because the practice is people doing the thing in the sentence. You know what the check is, because the check is you watching them do it. And you know what to cut, because anything that does not serve the sentence is not in this session.
Where they will do it, and with what
A performance has a setting. "Shape a loaf" is one thing on a floured wooden bench with a bench scraper, and another on a home countertop with a dinner knife. Ask the authority If your people will do this back at their own station, their own kitchen or their own desk, the setting that matters is theirs, not the one in your room. Write it down: "at their own bench, with the tools they already have." It will change what you demonstrate and what you supply, and it will save you from teaching a technique that depends on a tool nobody has.
The observation you will make
The last part of the test is the one most new teachers skip. Say in advance what you will watch for. Not "see if they got it", but the actual thing: the angle of the hand against the bench, the row inserted and the total updating, the finger landing on the right line of the bill. This is the beginning of a check, which Checks for understanding: finding out whether it landed builds properly, and it is also the only honest answer to "did the session work", which Did the training work? Finding out afterward, and changing the session deals with.
Backward design, which Indiana University's teaching center sets out on its page about backward course design, puts those steps in that order on purpose: state the result, decide what evidence would show it, work out what people need to do to produce that evidence, and only then choose the content and the activities. Convention The order is the useful part. Most sessions are built in the opposite direction, starting from what the teacher knows and what will fill the time, and the evidence step gets invented in the last ten minutes or skipped.
3. What a room buys you that a page does not
Suppose your sentence passes. The next question is whether this room, on this day, can give people a reasonable attempt at the thing in it.
This is a physical question, not a philosophical one. If the performance is "shape a round loaf" and you have ten people, five benches and a hundred and twenty minutes, then people get roughly half the bench time each, minus the demonstration, minus the opening and closing, minus the time the dough needs. That is the arithmetic the timing calculators do, and the answer is often smaller than people expect. If the performance is "enter a new client in the intake system" and the room has no computers, there is nothing to practice on and the session is a demonstration with an audience.
It would be easy to read this chapter as "sessions are usually the wrong form, so do not teach one." That is not the claim. A session with a clear performance and twenty minutes of real practice does something a document cannot: it is the only cheap way most people get to attempt a thing with an expert watching. The claim is narrower. A session with no performance behind it and no practice in it is a meeting, and it should be priced as one. What a single two-hour session achieves for your group is not something this manual can tell you, and neither can the research below: it depends on the skill, the people and what happens afterwards.
The other thing a room buys is information for you. You find out, in the moment, that four people hold the tool the wrong way, or that everyone thought the second column meant something else. A document gives you none of that. Physical principle Nothing about a page tells you where it failed; a room tells you if you ask. That is worth a great deal, and it is the reason to put checks in, which is the subject of Checks for understanding: finding out whether it landed.
The evidence people cite here, and what it actually covers
Somebody will tell you that active learning beats lecturing, citing a well-known meta-analysis. The figure is real and worth knowing precisely. Freeman and colleagues' 2014 analysis, Active learning increases student performance in science, engineering, and mathematics, found that performance on examinations and concept inventories rose by 0.47 standard deviations under active learning across 158 studies, and that students in traditional lecture courses were on average 1.5 times more likely to fail, from 67 studies.
Physical principle Here is the part that gets dropped: every study in that analysis is an undergraduate course in science, engineering or mathematics, compared over a term. It is a comparison of two ways of designing a semester, not a measurement of a two-hour workshop, and it says nothing about which individual minutes to spend how. It is a good reason to design a session around people doing things. It is not a basis for predicting what your Saturday morning will achieve, and anyone who quotes it that way has read the headline rather than the paper. Learning myths and other claims about teaching, and what their sources say sets this out beside six other claims you will hear.
4. What to send instead Go deeper
If the sentence does not pass, or the room cannot support practice, the session is not the only tool you have. Here is what the alternatives actually do.
| Form | What it does well | What it costs | What it cannot do |
|---|---|---|---|
| A one-page job aid | Sits beside the work and is read at the moment of need, for years | An afternoon to write, pennies to print | Give anyone a first attempt with someone watching |
| A short recorded demonstration | Shows the thing, pausable, replayable, from the best angle | Half a day, and it goes stale when the thing changes | Tell you what went wrong for the viewer |
| Ten minutes one to one | Diagnoses one person's actual problem and fixes it | Ten minutes per person, which does not scale | Reach ten people on a Tuesday |
| A written procedure | Settles what the agreed steps are, and can be audited | Writing and maintenance | Make anybody able to perform the steps |
| A session | Attempts, with an expert present, and the group seeing each other | Everyone's time at once, plus your preparation | Work without a performance and a way to practice it |
Two combinations are worth more than any of these alone. The first is a job aid plus a session: the session gets the first attempt, the job aid carries the rest home, which is what Slides, handouts and materials: what you give them and when is about. The second is a recorded demonstration watched before the session, so that the room's time goes to attempts rather than to watching. That second one asks people to do something in advance, which many will not, so plan for the version where half the room has not watched it.
Sessions whose real job is a decision
Some sessions are not teaching. They are a group making a decision, or a group being told something, wearing the clothes of a workshop because a workshop sounds better than a meeting. There is nothing wrong with a decision meeting. It is worth naming it, though, because the two have different shapes: a decision meeting needs the options written down in advance and someone with the authority to decide in the room, and it does not need a demonstration or practice. If your sentence keeps coming out as "everyone will be aligned on", you are planning a meeting.
5. Teaching it once, or teaching it for years Go deeper
How much preparation is worth doing depends on how many times you will do this. Three cases, and they call for different amounts of work.
- Once, and probably not again. Write the sentence, break the demonstration into steps, write one check. Skip the elaborate materials. Put your effort into the thing that leaves the room with people, because that is what survives.
- A few times a year. The sheets in your session plan earn their keep from the second run. The expensive part of teaching is working out what goes wrong and where the minutes go; once it is written down, the second run costs a fraction of the first.
- Often, or handing it to somebody else. Then the run sheet and the demonstration breakdown are the deliverable, and they want to be written so that a competent stranger could follow them. Teaching other people to teach it is a different subject and not one this manual covers.
One trap in the third case. A session you have run twenty times gets smooth, and smooth is not the same as effective. The smoothness is yours. Whether people leave able to do the thing is a separate question, and the only way to know is to keep checking, which is why After the workshop: what happened and what to change has a sheet for what people could actually do rather than for how it felt.
6. See it See it
Priya and the bread class. Priya Raman has been asked to teach a two-hour bread-shaping class at a community kitchen on a Saturday. Ten people have signed up. The kitchen has five benches and she can get in forty minutes early. She has not taught anything before.
Known: two hours, ten people, five benches, one helper (Ann, who has taken the class twice as a participant), a borrowed room with a forty-minute setup window.
Her first sentence: "People will understand how to shape bread." It fails the test: there is nothing to watch.
Her second sentence: "After this, one person will be able to shape a round loaf that holds its shape standing on the bench, at home, with their own hands and a bowl." That passes. It names a thing she can watch, and it names the setting as their own kitchen rather than hers.
What she cut: starter maintenance, hydration percentages, oven steam, scoring patterns. All of it is interesting and none of it serves the sentence. It goes on a not-today list, which she keeps, because a list is easier to leave alone than a deleted paragraph.
Assumed, and whose assumption it is: that ten people can get a reasonable number of attempts on five benches in what is left of two hours. That is Priya's assumption, and it is the one to test with the practice time calculator before she plans anything else.
Open, and who settles it: whether she can use the kitchen's dough, or whether everyone brings their own. The kitchen manager settles that, and Priya's answer changes how many attempts are possible.
Two free readings that do this better than any paid course page:
- Carnegie Mellon's Eberly Center on learning objectives: the completion prompt, the vague verbs to avoid, and the instruction to break a complex skill into its component skills. Two pages, and it is the whole of section 2 in its original form.
- Indiana University on backward course design: the three stages, in the order that puts the evidence before the activities. It is written for a semester course, and the order transfers to a two-hour session unchanged.
7. Practice Practice
Minimum: write one completed sentence and the observation you would make to see it. Time: about 30 minutes. Materials: a blank page, or the objectives sheet in your session plan.
- Write the sentence badly first. Finish "After this, one person will be able to" with whatever comes out. It will probably contain "understand" or "know about". That is fine; it is a draft.
- Find the verb you could film. Ask what the person would be doing with their hands, their mouth or their screen if they had understood. Replace the verb with that.
- Add the setting. Where will they do this, and with what, when you are not there?
- List five things you could teach about your subject, and cross out the ones that do not serve the sentence. Keep the crossed-out list.
- Write the observation. One sentence: "I would know because I would see them ______."
If your subject is large, do the first step three times, for three different people who might come: the one who knows nothing, the one who has tried and failed, and the one who has done it for years. The three sentences will differ, and the differences are the information Finding out what the room already knows asks you to collect. If your session has been handed to you with objectives somebody else wrote, write your own version alongside theirs; Writing learning objectives: what they will be able to do covers what to do about the gap.
8. Your session Your session
9. Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- Could a stranger read your sentence and know what to watch for, without asking you?
- Does the verb name something a person does, rather than something that happens inside their head?
- Does the sentence say where they will do it and with what?
- Can people attempt that thing in the room you have been given, with the equipment that will be there?
- Do you have a list of what you cut, rather than a vague sense that you dropped some things?
Worked example
Priya's sentence: "shape a round loaf that holds its shape standing on the bench, at home, with their own hands and a bowl." A stranger could watch for that. The verb is "shape", which is a thing hands do. The setting is named, and it is their kitchen rather than the community kitchen. Attempting it needs dough, bench space and about three minutes per attempt, which the room can supply for a limited number of attempts. Her not-today list has four items on it. The sentence passes on all five.
Common mistakes
- A sentence about the session rather than the person. "Cover the five stages of the process" describes your morning, not their ability.
- A performance that depends on your equipment. If the technique works with the kitchen's dough scraper and nobody owns one, you have taught something that will not survive the walk home.
- Three sentences joined with "and". That is three performances, and it is a decision disguised as a sentence. Split them and decide which survives.
- Deleting what you cut. You will be tempted to put it back at 11 p.m. the night before. A written not-today list is easier to leave alone.
What is still unresolved
This chapter does not tell you how many performances a session holds, how to order them, or how long any of it takes. Three to five is the usual answer and Writing learning objectives: what they will be able to do works out yours. Whether what you cut should have been cut is settled partly by what the group already knows, which is Finding out what the room already knows. Whether the whole thing fits the minutes you have is Workshop timing: minutes on paper and minutes in the room, and the answer there sometimes sends you back to this chapter to cut again.